The 10 Cheesecake Shops in Toronto [2022]

Cheesecake Shops in Toronto

The best cheesecake shops in Toronto are more than happy to sell you some tasty cheesecake!

Nothing compares to a slice of cheesecake! The not overly sweet, light, creamy, and delicate texture of cheesecakes needs a moment of appreciation. It might even be the very best dessert.

If you’re a cheesecake addict like us and looking for places to buy one in Toronto, we’ve got you covered! Toronto has tons of longtime bakery gems, as well as newer bakeries, all of which offer delicious and soft cheesecakes.

 

We chose these businesses based on affordability, different flavours and kinds of cheesecake, and of course the quality and taste of the actual cheesecakes. These Toronto cheesecake shops are the very best, so you can trust them to serve you some delicious cheesecake!

If you have a major sweet tooth, then Toronto is paradise. If you’re in the city, you have to visit the best ice cream desserts and the best Asian bakeries and desserts in Toronto!

Summary

What are the Most Popular Cheesecakes?

There are so many different flavours and variations of cheesecake, it can be hard to choose just one. If you’re looking for the most popular types, these are some of the best:
  1. New York Cheesecake: This is the classic cheesecake that we all know and love. It’s rich, dense, and has a thick graham cracker crust.
  1. Strawberry Cheesecake: A refreshing twist on the classic, this cheesecake is made with fresh strawberries and a delicious strawberry sauce.
  1. Chocolate Cheesecake: For all the chocolate lovers out there, this cheesecake is for you! It’s made with rich chocolate and has a chocolate crust.
  1. Blueberry Cheesecake: This flavour is perfect for summertime! It’s made with fresh blueberries and has a light and fluffy texture.
  1. Pumpkin Cheesecake: This is a seasonal favourite! It’s made with pumpkin puree, spices, and a ginger snap crust.

The Best Cheesecakes in Toronto

Now that you know some of the most popular cheesecakes, it’s time to find where to buy them! Here are the 9 best places for cheesecake in Toronto:

1. Cheesecake Factory

Toronto’s very own Cheesecake Factory is, without a doubt, one of the best places to get your hands on some of the most mouth-watering cheesecakes you’ll ever taste. Situated in the convenient location of Yorkdale Shopping Mall, this spot is perfect for anyone looking for a delicious dessert to satisfy their sweet tooth. 

And with an impressive range of flavours on offer – including red velvet, Oreo, caramel apple, Reese peanut butter and chocolate cheesecakes – there’s something to suit every palate. 

Prices start at just $9.50 per cake, making this spot an affordable option for those on a budget. What’s more, you can now order pick-up or delivery through DoorDash. So what are you waiting for? Pay the Cheesecake Factory a visit today and see for yourself why Drake is such a big fan!

Business Information:

3401 Dufferin St, North York, ON M6A 2T9
(416) 781-4477
locations.thecheesecakefactory.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“I had a great experience at the restaurant. It is usually always busy, so expect a 30-45 minute wait at peak times. The host and waitress that served us were amazing. Our waitress recommended the restaurants top and signature dishes. Food was also great. Overall, great customer experience!”
“The cheesecake factory’s vibes are always immaculate! We had to wait 2 hours for a table for 2 but walked around the mall while we waited. I recommend the banana cream cheesecake as it’s not too sweet , it’s light, fluffy and delightful. The servers are also super nice and pleasant in conversation.”

Pros

Cons

2. Cheese Garden

Cheese Garden is a Japanese cheesecake shop that has finally opened its doors to the downtown Toronto public. 

Their matcha Fromage cheesecake is famous for its light and fluffy texture, as well as its delicate matcha flavour. The Cheese Garden staff are always happy to recommend their favourite cheesecakes to customers, and with such a wide range of flavours available, there’s sure to be something for everyone. 

Whether you’re a fan of traditional cheesecake flavours or looking to try something new, the Cheese Garden is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth. So what are you waiting for? Head on down to Eaton Centre and taste the deliciousness for yourself!

Business Information:

 220 Yonge St Unit H017
(416) 792-0887
cheesegarden.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

“I have to give them 5 stars. The cakes I tried is tasty, decoration is on point, packaging is nice and amazing. My recommendations are everything :)) I tried the uji matcha tiramisu, matcha double formage, cheese tart. All is good and delicious.”
“How cute store & friendly staff. I always wanted to try their desserts but the Celebration of their 5 years was the best opportunity. I love the cheese tart. It’s has puff pastry and it’s so creamy. I still need to try the Japanese cheesecake.”

Pros

Cons

3. Wanda's Pie in The Sky

Although Wanda’s little bright corner store is primarily known for her excellent pies, many people don’t know that she also sells some of the best cheesecakes in town. Her cheesecakes are rich and creamy, and come in a variety of delicious flavours, including Lemon Chiffon, New York Style, French Style, Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse with a drizzle of caramel, and many more. 

You can also find special seasonal cheesecakes at her store, so keep an eye out for those. Whether you’re a fan of pie or cheesecake (or both), you’ll definitely want to check out Wanda’s little bright corner store the next time you’re in town.

Business Information:

287 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2M2
(416) 236-7585
wandaspieinthesky.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“This is a go-to for award winning mango cheesecake. The cookie crumb has a nice crunch, the cheesecake flavour lovely, but the show stopper is the mango mousse and mango puree...AMAZING! I drive from the other side of town for this, it is so good! Although I haven't tried much else, Wanda's gets a 5 of 5 from me for this alone!”
“1000% Recommended! The Coconut pie and the chocolate peanut were fantastic! Cozy place that offers plenty of variety of desserts with an excellent drip coffee.”

Pros

Cons

4. Bunner’s Bake Shop

Looking for a delicious treat that’s both vegan and gluten-free? Look no further than Bunners! This bakery offers an amazing selection of sweet pastries, including cinnamon buns, cupcakes, muffins, brownies, and cheesecakes. 

Their cheesecakes are made with a nut-free cashew cream base and come in a variety of mouthwatering flavours, including Chocolate Cheesecake, Blueberry Cheesecake, and Cherry Cheesecake, and Raspberry Lemon two-layer cheesecakes. 

Best of all, they offer both small and big sizes – perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth! So what are you waiting for? Head to Bunners today for a treat you won’t soon forget!

Business Information:

244 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2L7
(647) 350-2975
bunners.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

“Love this place since it opened. So much variety and options. It is always a great place to visit and eat. Staff is very helpful. Might be a bit pricey but sugar content is lower so it is not too sugary. Best vegan cucpake ever. Cheesecake is bomb too.”
“This place is awesome. We got a blueberry cheesecake for a birthday and it was VERY appreciated by the DF/GF birthday gal. Also their oat milk soft serve ice cream is delicious. And their staff is super friendly!!”

Pros

Cons

5. Pancho’s Bakery

At Pancho’s Bakery, you don’t have to choose between your two favourite desserts. The bakery’s churros cheesecakes combine the best of both worlds and come in a variety of delicious flavours. 

The original churros cheesecake is a creamy dessert topped with Dulce de Leche, pieces of toasted almonds, and churros. But that’s just the beginning. You can also order churros cheesecakes covered in chocolate, or with a filling of your choice.

And if you’re really feeling adventurous, try the churros ice cream sandwich. Order takeout or buy online with next-day delivery, usually between 12 and 6 pm. So what are you waiting for? Satisfy your sweet tooth today.

Business Information:

214 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2L4
(416) 854-8770
panchosbakery.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“Tried it for the first time and it was really good! Everyone loved it the churros were fresh and the cheesecake was amazing!”
“I got these delicious churros, one with chocolate and the other ones are plain. So yummm 🤤 and they also offer different kinds of Mexican food and they are all look great! I will definitely go back and try and will update my review…”

Pros

Cons

6. Dufflet Bakery

Dufflet is a stunning bakery that offers an extensive and delectable range of cakes and pastries. They have been serving the people of the town with lip-smacking desserts for almost four decades now. What makes Dufflet even more special is their wonderful customer service. 

Their highly trained and professional staff is always ready and willing to help you with anything you need, whether it’s picking out the perfect cake for your event or simply answering any questions you may have. 

And of course, let’s not forget their stunning cakes and pastries! From Berry Lemon cheesecake to Chocolate Marble Cheesecake, they have something for everyone. So if you’re ever in the mood for something sweet, be sure to check out Dufflet! You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:

787 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1G1
(416) 504-2870
dufflet.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“Ordered one of their cheesecakes as a dessert for a birthday. Everyone enjoyed it. It was beautiful, rich and delicious. The merengue on top was perfectly toasted. Their service was great, they gave instruction on keeping the cheesecake in good condition. Great place, would love to try one of their layer cakes.”
“I ordered a baby birthday cake for my daughter’s birthday party from online. Black and white flavour with filing chocolate cream and finished butter cream. It was really delicious and nice. We enjoyed a lot. Customer service was excellent and friendly. I would like to say Thank you Dufflet Pastries for giving a pleasant experience.”

Pros

Cons

7. Serano Bakery

If you enjoy Greek pastries, Serano Bakery is the place to go. For a reasonable price, they provide a variety of delicious, high-quality baked products, cakes, ice creams, cheesecakes, Baklava, and a variety of other desserts. 

They also feature some of the best and most creative cheesecakes in town, including Melomakarona Cheesecake, Baklava Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecakes, and many more, including seasonal specialties that you don’t want to miss out on. 

In addition to their delicious selection of baked goods, Serano Bakery also offers a wide range of other services, including custom cakes for all occasions, wedding cakes, and catering services. 

So if you’re looking for a place to get your Greek pastry fix, Serano Bakery is the place to go.

Business Information:

830 Pape Ave, East York, ON M4K 3T5
(416) 462-2735
seranobakery.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“This European bakery is a sweet tooth's absolute dream—they have a wide variety of beautiful and decadent pastries and everything is at a super reasonable price. Some of my favourites include the melomakarono cheesecake and the nougatina.”
“This is my go to bakery to get cakes for family events. For Easter I ordered the Tiramisu cake and a cheesecake. They were both amazing. The prices are good and I order online and pick up at their outside window. Nothing could be easier.”

Pros

Cons

8. Uncle Tetsu

Uncle Tetsu is famous for their delicious and light Japanese cheesecakes. If you’re looking for a cheesecake that isn’t overly sweet, buttery, and with a very soft texture, Uncle Tetsu is the place to go. The shop greets you with a heavenly scent of treats and a kind and polite staff to assist you with your options where you can only buy an entire cheesecake as they don’t offer slices. 

The unique feature of their delectable cheesecakes is that they don’t contain any soy, sesame oil, peanut oil, shellfish, or any nut, as all of their ingredients are produced in a nut-free facility. 

Uncle Tetsu has numerous locations around Toronto, and you can visit their downtown location today, which is a minute away from Ryerson University. Whether you have a sweet tooth or not, Uncle Tetsu’s Japanese cheesecakes are definitely worth trying at least once in your life!

Business Information:

598 Bay St., Toronto, ON M5G 1M5
(437) 266-9196
ncletetsu-ca.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“Everyone throughout Canada I crossed raved about Uncle Tetsu's. After my visit to this location I can definitely see why! These delicious jiggly little (not so little) cheesecakes were the most amazing dessert I've had in a while. For someone with not a sweet tooth in her body this cheesecake was light, airy and flavorful.The cute little stamp was a huge bonus. Please so yourself a favor if you're in the area. You won't be sorry at all.”
“Amazing Japanese Cheesecake. Light, fluffy, melt-in-your mouth goodness. We like that is not too heavy. Highly recommend trying dipping it in the chocolate fondue. The rusks and tarts are excellent to snack on as well. They are quite reasonably priced and always freshly made. Now that there are more Uncle Tetsu's locations, there aren't such long line as this one anymore, so we are glad for the shorter wait time.”

Pros

Cons

9. Carole's Cheesecake Cafe

Carole’s Cheesecake Cafe, located in Yorkville, provides some of the best pastries in Toronto. Carole has been baking for almost 40 years and has won several awards, including the best dessert award in Toronto. 

They make their cakes entirely by hand, using only the finest natural ingredients. Carol’s cheesecakes are just as good as her other pastries: soft, moist, and light, with a creamy texture that everyone likes. 

Be sure to try out their caramel brownie cheesecake, red velvet cheesecake, pistachio cheesecake, lemon cheesecake, and gluten-free cheesecakes such as Dolce De Leche cheesecake and strawberry cheesecakes. 

Don’t miss out on their dipped mini cheesecake sticks with your choice of toppings, which are both interesting to see and delightful to eat. With such amazing food, it’s no wonder Carole’s Cheesecake Cafe is one of the best places to get dessert in Toronto.

Business Information:

114 Cumberland St, Toronto, ON M5S 2W7
(416) 849-1499
carolescheesecake.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

“the first time i came here was after class with my friend who is also a cheesecake addict like me. we still talk about this place and how we need to visit again together. whenever i am in the area and i am craving something sweet, this is where i come. the carrot cake is blessed!”
“We went here as a family and tried 3 different cheesecakes (see pictures). We had a mango kind of tea to go with them. One of the best cheesecakes I've ever had. Their staff was excellent and humorous. Highly recommended and would definitely come back.”

Pros

Cons

10. Soft Dough Co. Bakery

At Soft Dough Co., they believe that good food leads to a good mood. And what better way to unwind than with a delicious dessert? From birthday cakes to after-dinner treats, their selection of cheesecakes is sure to please any sweet tooth. 

Their choco basque cheesecake is a rich and decadent chocolate lovers dream, while their basque burnt cheesecake is a timeless classic with a modern twist. So whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a little pick-me-up, be sure to stop by Soft Dough Co. for a slice of happiness.

Business Information:

28 Bathurst St unit 1-103, Toronto, ON M5V 0C6
softdoughco.com

Customer Review Highlight:

“We bought a madeleines set and a Basque burnt cheesecake. The madeleines set had 6 flavours, all great, among them I liked the most the plain, sesame seed and green tea. Yet, the cheesecake turned out to be at another level. Simply delicious.”
“Love the cheesecake and the madeleines. Very fresh and tasty. We ordered set of 6 assorted madeleines and 2 slices of the cheesecake with stawberry sauce. For the madeleines we got 2 cinnamon, 2 almonds and 2 coconuts. Ordering is very easy online. You get an email after you order online with instructions where to pick it up or get it delivered. We picked it up from Bathurst and lakeshore opposite of Loblaw's where the statue are. Will definitely order it again.”

Pros

Cons

FAQs About Cheesecake

Unfortunately, cheesecake is not particularly healthy. It’s a decadent dessert and its calorie count, and amount of sugar and fat reflects that. For a healthier cheesecake, visit one of the Japanese cheesecake shops on the list. This style of cheesecake has fewer calories and less sugar.
Typically, cheesecakes will last for 3-4 days in the fridge.
The best way to store cheesecake is in an airtight container in the fridge.
Yes, cheesecake can be made vegan. In place of typical cheesecakes made from cheese, many bakeries offer tofu cheesecakes. Today, there are vegan cream cheeses, so there are many cheesecake options for vegans.

Final Thoughts

These Toronto cheesecake shops are serving up everything from traditional cheesecakes, to Japanese cheesecake, and unique offerings like churro-flavoured cheesecake. Whatever kind of cheesecake you want, there’s definitely a Toronto shop for you.

If you’re looking for a great place or two to buy cheesecake from, you can’t go wrong with any of the best Toronto cheesecake shops.

You might also like...