The 15 Best Cookie Stores in Toronto [2023]

Best Cookie Stores in Toronto

Get ready to embark on a delectable journey through Toronto’s cookie wonderland! Craving something sweet and sensational? Look no further. We’re about to reveal the city’s crème de la crème – the 15 best cookie shops that will redefine your cookie cravings and leave you craving for more. 

From mouth-watering classics to innovative confections, these cookie havens are a true treat for your taste buds. Join us as we unravel the aromatic delights and melt-in-your-mouth magic that Toronto’s top cookie shops have to offer!

Summary

Why Are Crumbl Cookies So Popular In Toronto?

Crumbl Cookies is super popular in Toronto because:

  • Cool Flavors: They make different and exciting cookie flavors that people really like to try.
  • Good Ingredients: Crumbl uses good stuff to make their cookies taste amazing.
  • Looks Yummy: The cookies look really good, and the packaging is nice too. People like to share or give them as gifts.
  • Online Fun: They show pictures of their cookies on the computer, and people get excited and want to buy them.
  • Feels Local: Crumbl is part of the community, and that makes people like them even more.
  • Tastes Awesome: When you eat their cookies, they’re soft and crunchy in the right way. People feel happy when they eat them.
  • Choices for Everyone: They have many flavors, even for people who can’t eat certain things.
  • Sharing Fun: People enjoy eating these cookies with friends and family, so it’s like a happy thing to share.

So, Crumbl Cookies is a hit in Toronto because of their tasty and unique flavors, good ingredients, nice looks, and the joy of sharing them with others.

The Top Cookie Stores in Toronto

Well, why wait any longer? Let’s jump right into Toronto’s best cookie shops!

1. Craig's Cookies

If you’re a cookie enthusiast in Toronto, Craig’s Cookies is an absolute must-visit destination! Founded by the passionate baker, Craig, this charming cookie shop has been delighting customers since 2013. What sets Craig’s Cookies apart is their extensive menu of over 100 flavors, ensuring there’s something for every taste bud. 

From classic chocolate chip to inventive and exciting combinations, each cookie is packed with mouth-watering flavors that keep customers coming back for more. So, if you’re in Toronto, don’t miss the chance to savor these delectable treats and be part of the delightful experience at Craig’s Cookies!

Business Information:

Address: 1537A Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6R 1A7
Phone: (416) 519-5336
Website: craigscookies.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"I have nothing but good things to say about these cookies. They’re soft and chewy at the center but crispy on the sides. We ordered the classic chocolate chip cookies and we absolutely loved them. They’re salty but sweet and they’ve got a good amount of chocolate which it’s always expected for my taste. Lovely staff, fair prices for handmade cookies and they’ve got a vast selection of flavors. Definitely recommend Craig’s cookies! "
- Minerva A.
"My wife's company had a social gathering and she came home with Craig's Cookies. There was a box of 5 or 6 cookies in an assortment of flavours. They were all delicious and moist. Each cookie is the perfect size for sharing with a partner. I honestly can't say which one was my favourite."
- Jeremy Dang

2. Bake Sale Toronto

Bake Sale is the place to go for all your cookie needs! They offer a variety of homemade goodies, including cupcakes, cakes and cookies of course. Their cookies are made round and thin, making them enjoyable with every bite.Not only do they have delicious cookies fresh from their ovens, but you can also buy them frozen so that you can bake them at home whenever you want.

Some of the unique flavours that they offer include ‘Funfetti’ (birthday cake flavoured), ‘Peanut Butter, ‘Chocolate Chip Shortbread’, ‘Monster’ and ‘Double Chocolate’. They also currently offer holiday-themed baked goods and gifts – including holiday-themed cookies!

Business Information:

Address: 2300 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M6S 1P2
Phone: (416) 763-1818
Website: bakesaletoronto.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"I love this shop! When looking to try a new bakery I always try their chocolate chip cookie because a good bakery needs to nail this classic. Bake sale hands down has the best chocolate chip cookie in the area and they sell them in their freezer so you can pop a cookie or two (or twelve) in the oven at home!"
- Alex St.Germain
"Cupcakes, cookies, cakes are delicious! They always have the cutest window displays and the staff is super friendly. I have yet to find a better cupcake anywhere!"
- Amanda K

3. Robyn's Cookies

Robyn’s Cookies, situated near Lawrence Ave. and Ranleigh Ave., prides itself on using top-quality, local ingredients. Their preservative-free, handcrafted cookies boast flavors like ‘Chocolate Chip,’ ‘Salted Chocolate Chunk,’ ‘Chewy Ginger,’ and ‘Oatmeal Dark Chocolate.’ 

A delight for chocolate chip enthusiasts, these cookies strike a perfect balance between crispy edges and a chewy center. The chocolate’s slight bitterness complements the toffee’s sweetness, while a touch of buttery flavor adds a non-greasy, satisfying touch!

Business Information:

Address: 3215 Yonge Street Rear Building, Enter Off, Ranleigh Ave, Toronto, ON M4N 2L3
Phone: (416) 489-8497
Website: robynscookies.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"I started my day with a visit to Robyn's cookies. I needed cookies for a client meeting and extras of course! My favourites are the Chocolate Chip, Junk in My Trunk and Gingerbread for my son. I love these cookies. Also the people who work there are always so nice. I had a great chat this morning and started my day out really well. Who cares if I arrived at my meeting covered in powder sugar!! "
- Shannon Shorten
"Some of the best chocolate chip cookies and dark chocolate oatmeal cookies in the Yonge and Lawrence area, possibly in Toronto! I highly recommend dropping by this hideaway and see what they have to offer. "
- Ehren Cheung

4. The Night Baker

The Night Baker, founded by Toronto baking duo Mitch and Leanne, brings a chemist’s precision and a passion for inventive recipes to crafting incredibly delicious and creative cookies. Drawing from years of experience, their soft and chewy cookies are a treat for your sweet cravings

From classic dark chocolate with walnut and sea salt to a variety of unique flavors, The Night Baker offers something for everyone to enjoy. With cookies as one of life’s simple pleasures, it’s a must-visit destination!

Business Information:

Address: 825 College St, Toronto, ON M6G 1C9
Phone: (416) 901-5590
Website: thenightbaker.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"Scrumptious, hand-made cookies that are always soft, chewy and absolutely delicious. I may be a bit boring in my flavour choices when I go, but they still have some of the most unique and boldly inspired flavours I’ve ever tried! "
- Elliot Harris
"Amazing cookie spot, tried an assortment of cookies and each one was really good. The cookies were full of flavour and really soft too. Might be one of the best cookie places in Toronto. "
- Ian Dela Cruz

5. Sweet Flour Bake Shop

Sweet Flour Bake Shop specializes in delightful cookie and cupcake gifts, along with other gourmet baked goodies. Its chic design makes it the ultimate destination for those seeking to share delectable treats. With a marvelous array of cookie flavors, a dozen assorted mix cookies is a must-try recommendation. 

From Almond Toffee Milk Chocolate to Butterscotch Toffee, Chocolate Chunk, Red Velvet, and White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, there’s a flavor for every palate. Health-conscious options like gluten-free cookies are also available. Remarkable presentation and unwavering quality ensure a consistently satisfying experience.

Business Information:

Address: 130 Cawthra Ave #105, Toronto, ON M6N 3C2
Phone: (416) 763-2253
Website: sweetflour.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

"My mother just received a beautiful delivery from sweet flour bake shop for Mother’s Day from my sister who lives in Montreal. The cookies were just fabulous great selection fresh and tasty. What a delicious sweet surprise. "
- Chloe Lovell
"Do you love cookies? Do you love making your family happy? Sweet Flour Bake Shop is the place that brings warmth to both the body and the soul. This is one of my favorite bakeries in the city. Do what it takes to get here."
- Jeff Brecker

6. Courage Cookies

Discover Courage Cookies, a delightful cookie haven in Toronto! With their ever-changing menu of over 30 rotating flavors, this bakery promises to keep your taste buds intrigued and excited with every visit. What sets Courage Cookies apart is their dedication to inclusivity by offering both gluten-friendly and vegan options, ensuring that everyone can indulge in their scrumptious treats. 

Whether you’re a cookie connoisseur or just someone looking for a delightful sweet treat, Courage Cookies is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings and embark on a delicious journey through their delectable offerings. Don’t miss out on the chance to taste courage in every bite at this exceptional Toronto cookie shop!

Business Information:

Address: 28 Bathurst St #1-104, Toronto, ON M5V 0R4
Phone: (647) 689-5911
Website: couragecookies.ca 

Customer Review Highlight:

"Seriously best cookies I ever had, I got a pack of 6 different cookies and have been nibbling on all them since I can't decide which one is my fave. Also the sweetness level and portion is perfect, my sugar crave on my coffee time got easily satisfied with half of the cookie. "
- Melisa Cecilia
"If you are waiting to try these cookies.... DO IT. It is true that these are the best cookies out there. I ordered them to Victoria and they made the trip perfectly. I tried every single kind last night and I couldn’t stop. Can’t wait to eat more tonight... do it!!! Order now they are delicious!"
- Laura Palmer

7. Golden Crumb

If you’re looking for a delicious, gourmet cookie that’s bigger than your average size then look no further than Golden Crumb! They are an online-based bakery that specializes in JUMBO cookies – and they are definitely one of the best ones in Toronto. Apart from their beautiful aesthetic, their cookies are soft and chewy with the perfect level of crispiness around the edges. Plus, they love Nutella! So you can expect to find flavours such as Nutella, Lindt and Cadbury infused into some of their most popular recipes.

From classic chocolate chips to vibrant pistachio – there’s something for everyone at Golden Crumb! And what makes it even better is that they use high-quality ingredients like real chocolate and nuts to create intense flavour profiles that will leave your taste buds wanting more.

Business Information:

Phone: (437) 344-5050
Website: goldencrumbbiscuit.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"I've ordered from Golden Crumb on two different occasions and each time has been amazing! The cookies are so soft and tasty and I look forward to trying more of their flavours. "
- Ana Gomez
"The best selection of cookies I've ever had! Highly recommend for large parties... customer service was fantastic. Farhan and his team responded to my request very quickly!! Great experience... 10/10!!! Would highly recommend the mini eggs one!!! "
- Musa Raveendran

8. Biscotteria Forno Cultura

Biscotteria Forno Cultura is all about unique, quality and hand-made Italian cookies. They celebrate the art of making these delicious treats by showcasing the beauty of flavours in simple and honest forms. This is the place to go for all your Italian cookie needs! They always have some cookies on hand for tasting, so you can find the perfect flavour before buying a box filled with a wide range of delicious cookies that are rich in flavour and not overly sweet.

From classics such as chocolate chip to more inventive options like their signature fig & balsamic cookie, there’s something for everyone here! Plus, everything is made fresh on-site so you know that you’re getting the best possible quality – perfect for those special occasions when only an authentic Italian cookie will do.

Business Information:

Address: 65 Front St W, Toronto, ON M5J 1E6
Phone: (416) 214-5656
Website: fornocultura.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"I love their hand-drip coffee and cookies as well. They make cookies not too sweet so it is tasty for me and feel healthy. I highly recommend that place! If I lived in downtown I would go everyday to get a cup of coffee"
- U U
"If you're looking for the finest of Italy and a friendly welcoming environment, make sure you stop by Biscotteria at Union station. This location is very different than then others. The store manager Manon, and the entire team are very nice to talk to. Coffees, cookies and everything they have is quite delicate and rare to find in Toronto. Obviosly, my favorite bakery and coffee store"
- Banu P

9. Butter Baker

If you’re looking for a bakery that offers an evolving selection of sweet and savoury pastries, then Butter Baker is the place for you! Located in the heart of downtown Toronto on Dundas St, just West of Bay St, it’s within walking distance of Eaton center – making it the perfect spot to stop by while shopping. All their pastries are made with classic French confectionery cookery and techniques, using only local ingredients like fresh herbs and free-run eggs.

Their butterscotch cookie is a real winner – it’s buttery, sweet and chewy all at the same time. Another favourite is the matcha white chocolate cookie! It’s not too sweet so you can enjoy it without having to worry about your sugar levels skyrocketing.

Business Information:

Address: 120 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M5G 1C3
Phone: (416) 971-8686
Website: butter-baker.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"This place is the bomb. I have never had dessert so good as butter baker. Their matchamisu is out of this world and for me they have the best cookies I have ever tasted. I’ve tried 3 cookies which was the matcha cookie, the birthday cake cookie and the caramel cookie. All soft and chewy when you bite it but crunchy on the outside. The way they make it is perfection. You just have to try to see what I mean."
- Sheena Yap Chan
"Nice bakery near the city hall of Toronto. Pastries were fresh and delicious. Had the macha cookie and banana caramel cookie, which were amazing. Nice and cozy to relax and get some desserts after lunch."
- Miguel Chang

10. The Sweet Escape

The Sweet Escape Patisserie, established in May 2008, is a haven for dessert lovers. Renowned for their imaginative twists on beloved classics, they use premium ingredients and offer an impressive selection of over 30 types of shortbread. With expertise in crafting exceptional cookies, their soft cookie range includes enticing options like Chocolate Crinkle, Caramelized White Chocolate Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Smoked Chocolate, Toffee & Sea Salt, and more. 

Notably, they cater to various diets, presenting gluten-free and vegan choices. No matter your preferences, this patisserie guarantees a delectable treat to satisfy your cravings!

Business Information:

Address: 24 Tank House Lane Unit 102, Toronto, ON M5A 3C4
Phone: (416) 214-2253
Website: thesweetescapedistillery.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"Have had many items cakes, cookies ,squares , ice cream, sandwiches and soup.. At Christmas time I love the cookie trees makes a fantastic hosted gift or an item for a dessert buffet. They make beautiful special occasion cakes as well"
- Karen Poynton
"Thank you to The Sweet Escape for the delicious birthday cake, cheesecake, cookies, & tiramisu you prepared to help celebrate my friend's birthday and first home in Corktown. The cheesecake got the highest praise from all 7 of us and I highly recommend it (it's not something I go for regularly elsewhere but this one tasted so good)! I am glad this local business is nearby; I hope to return in the future for our next special occasion."
- Vincent LaGuardia Gambini

11. Bunner’s Bake Shop

Bunner’s Bakeshop has been providing delicious vegan and gluten-free baked goods since 2010. Their traditional recipes are so good that you won’t be able to tell the difference between them and their classic counterparts! Here you will find beautiful celebration cakes, jumbo muffins, decadent cupcakes and of course cookies!

This bakeshop offers delicious cookie flavours, including a classic flavour in the ‘Chocolate Chunk Cookie’ and unique flavours including the ‘Supersonic Cookie’. Whether you’re looking for something chocolatey or want to try something new, they’ve got you covered!

Business Information:

Address: 244 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2L7
Phone: (647) 350-2975
Website: bunners.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

"Went there to treat myself on some vegan goodies and got the Brownie, the chocolate chip cookie and a cinnamon bun - it was SO GOOD! The cinnamon bun had the most delicious vanilla frosting on it and both the Brownie and the cookie were super doughy and delicious. Definitely go there if you're vegan and want to treat yourself "
- brinsky
"Perfect vegan treats!got chocolate chip cookie that was soft and perfect and their coconut yogurt parfait with fresh fruits and homemade granola so creamy and good."
- Alexandra Zhuravel

12. Midnight Cookie

Craving a delicious late-night treat in Toronto? Look no further than Midnight Cookie! This unique cookie shop was born out of a desire to find the perfect late-night snack during the pandemic’s cold winter months in 2021. Fueled by passion and determination, the founders embarked on a cookie baking journey, conducting countless tests and baking sessions to create the ultimate cookie experience. 

Every cookie is made to order and delivered straight to your door, so you can enjoy them just like you baked them yourself. Whether it’s a midnight craving or any time of the day, Midnight Cookie has got you covered – they stay open until 3:00 am on weekends! So, if you’re in Toronto and in need of a scrumptious and comforting cookie fix, don’t hesitate to reach out to Midnight Cookie for a delightful treat!

Business Information:

Address: 3 Manor Rd E, Toronto, ON M4S 1P8
Phone: +16473489852
Website: http://www.midnightcookie.ca/

Customer Review Highlight:

“They serve the most delicious and most fresh cookies right out of the oven. You have a choice of ordering your own batch and wait 15 minutes for them to cook or just take the ones that are fresh out of the oven. They have variety of flavours. We got 6 cookies in 5 different flavours and they were all AMAZING. The staff were super helpful and friendly as well. I will definitely come back and bring all my friends too :))”
- fatemah dadvar
“I had the pleasure of trying Midnight Cookie’s delicious cookies recently and I have to say, they exceeded my expectations! Not only were the cookies incredibly tasty, but the service was also great. The staff were friendly and attentive, and made sure I had everything I needed. I highly recommend giving Midnight Cookies a try, you won't be disappointed! Oh, and their prices are unbeatable!”
- Sara Morad

13. Bakerbots Baking

Discover the heartwarming delights of Bakerbots Baking, a charming small-batch neighbourhood bakery in Toronto. At Bakerbots, every cookie is a labor of love, made entirely from scratch each day. Their commitment to freshness and quality shines through in every bite, making them a favorite among locals. With a focus on small batches, you can expect exceptional attention to detail and flavors that truly stand out. 

Whether you’re a cookie aficionado or just seeking the perfect sweet treat, Bakerbots Baking is the place to indulge in mouth-watering cookies that capture the essence of homemade goodness. So, if you’re in Toronto and want to experience the joy of freshly baked cookies, head over to Bakerbots Baking and treat yourself to a delightful cookie experience like no other!

Business Information:

Address: 205 Delaware Ave, Toronto, ON M6H 2T4
Phone: +14169013500
Website: http://bakerbotsbaking.com/

Customer Review Highlight:

“AMAZING bakery and at a really good price range considering the quality. We ordered several desserts such as the key lime pie, cinnamon roll, merengue pie cheese cake, peanut butter rice crispy square, and a few other items that we picked off based on how they looked. Everything was spectacular. You can order cakes from here but need to order at least two weeks in advance.”
- Victoria Figueroa
“The ice cream, the cookies, the brownies, freaking everything here is delicious! Holy moly! I recommend this place so much. Fun and classic flavours. Amazing cookie sandwiches. Totally tasty. Wonderful staff. Truly you can’t go wrong here.”
- Victoria Reedman

14. Mos Mos Coffee & Cookie Shop

Step into Mos Mos Coffee & Cookie Shop, where the worlds of delicious cookies and fitness collide in the most delectable way! This Toronto-based coffee shop is renowned for its unique specialties, the Fitness Cookie, and the Protein Power Cookie. These cookies are specially crafted to not only satisfy your sweet cravings but also provide a boost of nutrition and energy. 

Perfect for health-conscious individuals and fitness enthusiasts, Mos Mos takes cookie indulgence to a whole new level. Whether you’re refueling after a workout or simply looking for a guilt-free treat, their Fitness Cookie and Protein Power Cookie are the perfect companions. So, if you’re in the Bay Elm area of Toronto, don’t miss the chance to experience the best of both worlds at Mos Mos Coffee & Cookie Shop – where flavor meets fitness in every bite!

Business Information:

Address: 655 Bay St., Toronto, ON M5G 2K4
Phone: +16479477755
Website: https://ritual.co/order/mos-mos-coffee-bay-elm-toronto/e552

Customer Review Highlight:

“Surprisingly some of the best cookies in town. Crispy edges and chewy center like I wish all cookies are. The boxes are cute and not too expensive. High recommend the cookies and cream and chocolate caramel. The peanut butter one was a bit of a downer.”
- Flawnson Tong
“This place is truly something else. Amazing coffee, deliciously addicting cookies/yummy baked treats and a team of wonderful staff. Thank you kindly for your instrumental support for front line nurses. We truly felt the love through the wonderful treats today! Thank you again for making our nursing week a truly special one. I am confident to say, your location has now gained a massive fanbase of operating room nurses ❤️”
- Jess M

15. The Happy Bakers

Discover The Happy Bakers, a charming boutique café and bakery nestled at 3469 Lake Shore Blvd West in Toronto. This delightful bakery is a labor of love, brought to life by a group of passionate individuals who dreamed of having their own little bakeries. Combining their talents and love for baking, they offer an array of classic homemade sweet and savory treats that will warm your heart and satisfy your cravings. 

From scrumptious scones and cookies to mouth-watering squares, butter tarts, delectable pies, and cupcakes, The Happy Bakers have something for everyone. With each treat baked with love and a smile, their passion shines through in every bite. So, drop by and immerse yourself in the delectable world of The Happy Bakers – where every treat is a testament to their dedication and happiness in baking!

Business Information:

Address: 3469 Lake Shore Blvd W, Toronto, ON M8W 1N2
Phone: +14167089525
Website: http://www.thehappybakers.com/

Customer Review Highlight:

“Love this gem of a bakery. Just placed our first order ever and the cookies were incredible! From the finest ingredients to the display we loved it all! Our new go too . Customer service was incredible!”
- toe knee
“Lovely selection of baked goods made from the heart. Independently owned and operated. Specialties include shortbread, sugar cookies, pies, scones and dessert bars. They are expanding lunch offerings with chilli, soup, grilled and sandwiches. Coffee is espresso based and rich and delicious.”
- Melissa McColl

FAQ About Cookies

Hands down it is the chocolate chip cookie. You can find them anywhere and they are always a hit.
Gourmet cookies are hand-baked from scratch, unique and delicious! They usually incorporate quality ingredients like good-quality chocolate chips.

Homemade ones last 1 to 2 weeks at room temperature, 2 to 3 weeks in the fridge, or months in the freezer. Packaged cookies last weeks to months, while freshly baked ones are best enjoyed within days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature.

Vegan cookies are made without any dairy products. They can be made with almond milk, coconut milk or soy milk.

Conclusion

In Toronto, cookie stores are plentiful and choosing the best can be overwhelming. That’s why we’ve narrowed it down to the top 15. From classic chocolate chip to innovative flavors, these spots have something for everyone. Embark on a tasting adventure and find your favorite!

For more delicious treats in Toronto, don’t miss out on these sweet havens:

Picture of Veronika Zotova

Veronika Zotova

Veronika Zotova is marketing manager at Local View Tech. She was born and raised in Kyiv, Ukraine. Learn More About Veronika Zotova

You might also like...