The 4 Best Crawfish Restaurants in Toronto [2022]

Best Crawfish Restaurants in Toronto

Crawfish, also known as crayfish and crawdads, are one of the most delicious and underrated foods out there. If you’re looking for sweet, yet salty, perfectly cooked crawfish, you really can’t go wrong with any of the eateries on this list. At these restaurants, you can also try a variety of other seafood and many excellent sides to pair with your crawfish.

Seafood lovers in Toronto can delight in the fact that we found the best crawfish places in the city. Based on customer reviews, quality and freshness of the fish, and taste, we’re certain you will just love these crawfish restaurants. Whether you get your seafood fix boiled, fried, or in a po’boy sandwich, you really can’t go wrong.

If you want to see what else the Toronto seafood scene has to offer, check out our list of the top fish and chips in Toronto or the best Chinese seafood restaurants in Toronto!


How to Properly Eat Crawfish?

This may be your first time eating crawfish, and if so, you may be wondering how to properly go about it. Don’t worry, we’re here to help.

Start by holding the crawfish by the head and tail. You will then want to break off the large claws. Next, peel off the shell starting from the head end. You can then remove the gills and any remaining guts. What you’re left with is the tail meat, which is what you will want to eat.

Some people like to suck the head for extra flavour, but this is entirely up to you. Many find it too fishy tasting.

Of course, you can’t enjoy crawfish without the perfect dipping sauce. A little bit of melted butter and some Cajun seasoning is all you need to enhance the natural flavours of the seafood.

Now that you know how to properly eat crawfish, let’s get to the good stuff and take a look at the best crawfish places in Toronto!

The Best Crawfish in Toronto

Now that you know how to properly eat crawfish, it’s time to find the best place to enjoy them. Here are our top 4 picks for the best crawfish restaurants in Toronto.

1. Mermaids Find

Mermaids Find is a quality seafood restaurant where you will be able to find a variety of delicious dishes to eat made from all sorts of underwater critters, including crawfish. 

The Mermaid’s Blend sauce is absolutely delicious, the garlic butter is so yummy. This is not you’re average seafood boil the different flavours are incredible and the customization options cause a flavour explosion in your mouth! 

We highly recommend the Seafood Platter it comes with everything, shrimp, crab legs, lobster, and of course Crawfish. So if you’re ever in the area and you’re looking for a quality seafood meal then head on down to Mermaids Find. You won’t regret it!

Business Information:

705 – A Lawrence Ave W, North York, ON M6A 1B4

Customer Review Highlight:

“I have order from this place 4x already and i enjoy the service and the meal!! Definitely will be recommended and will be going back! Keep up the good work and service..if so you will always have my money and patronage.”

2. New Orleans Seafood & Steakhouse

Looking for a good seafood restaurant in New Orleans? Look no further than Seafood & Steakhouse. This tastefully decorated seafood spot offers a wide variety of delicious seafood dishes, all made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. They change their specials weekly, so there’s always something new to try. 

And their Jambalaya is definitely worth a try – it comes with a mix of andouille sausage, chicken, shrimp, and daily fresh fish, all baked in long grain rice and creole sauce and topped with mussels and crawfish. 

So come on down to Seafood & Steakhouse for a good quality meal that won’t disappoint.

Business Information:

267 Scarlett Rd, York, ON M6N 4K9

Customer Review Highlight:

“Loved the atmosphere and the quality of food. I ordered the seafood plate and it was really great. The service is amazing and the staff are polite.”

3. The Captain's Boil

The Captain’s Boil is a seafood restaurant that prepares fresh seafood feasts that diners can look forward to indulging with friends and family. You will find an extensive delicious menu of either individual or feast-sized dishes with them on top of other delicious looking items. 

For example, you could get the lobster, shrimp, crawfish (all with Captain’s Boil sauce), and seafood fried rice. Everything came in pretty large portions – very reasonable amount given the price. The sauce was delicious and the seafood was fresh and tasty.

All in all, you’ll enjoy a great meal here if you’re looking for a good seafood feast!

Business Information:

476 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4Y 1X5
(647) 348-7808

Customer Review Highlight:

“Super fun eating experience. We got the crawfish with corn. It is spicy, messy, and delicious. They give you these hilarious bibs to wear + plastic gloves. We've recommended the place to others and heard they loved it too!”

4. Robot Boil House

If you’re in the mood for seafood, Robot Boil House is the perfect spot. They offer a wide range of seafood options, from shrimp to mussels to clams, as well as the opportunity to create your own custom seafood platter. 

The mixed seafood combo is a great way to try a little bit of everything – it comes with 2 pcs of shrimps, mussels, clams, crawfish, chicken slices, and two choices of veggies and rice. And be sure to get the robot blend mix for your sauce – it’s delicious! 

Whether you’re in the mood for something simple or something more exotic, Robot Boil House has you covered.

Business Information:

895 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4W 2H2

Customer Review Highlight:

“I absolutely adored my visit to Robot boil house. Their menu is simple and easy to read, they’ve got nice drink options and it’s so nice to be received and served by a cute robot. We chose the robot house blend and it was absolutely yummy. The seafood is fresh and the oysters were on point. The experience exceeded my expectations, the price for it was within the affordable range. Definitely coming back for more!”

FAQS About Crawfish

No, crawfish and lobster are not the same. Crawfish are actually more closely related to shrimp. They are both decapod crustaceans, but lobster is in the infraorder Nephropsidae while crawfish is in the family Parastacidae.
Crawfish tastes like a cross between shrimp and lobster. It is sweet and delicately flavoured.
Yes, you should remove the shell before eating. The tail meat is the only edible part.
Crawfish is an excellent way to add protein to your diet. The fish is filled with vitamin B. However, the sauces and seasonings can be filled with sodium and calories. You should also keep in mind that they have dietary cholesterol. Like all things, in moderation, you can eat whatever style of crawfish you like.

Final Thoughts

In Toronto, there are all kinds of eateries that serve crawfish. If you’re looking for a more low-key, casual hangout or an upscale dinery, there’s something for everyone in the city. There’s nothing quite like a heaping of fresh, piping hot crawfish!

You might also like...