The 11 Best Halloween Costume Stores in Toronto [2022]

Best Halloween Costume Stores in Toronto

Halloween is one of the scariest times of the year, but you shouldn’t be scared of going costumeless! Whether you’re looking for the usual suspects like vampires or werewolves, or more elaborate costumes, these Toronto Halloween costume stores have got you covered. 

These retailers were chosen based on customer reviews, price point, their variety of costumes, and eagerness to find you the perfect costume. Whether you’re on a budget or want to splurge on a designer costume, one of these stores is sure to have what you need.

Get ready for trick-or-treaters by checking out the best candy stores in Toronto. 

Thrift stores are also a budget-friendly option if you want to buy clothes that can be worn not just for Halloween.


What's the Average Cost of a Halloween Costume?

The average cost of a Halloween costume is $31.52 – $62.75. However, the price of your costume will depend on where you shop and how elaborate your costume is. If you’re looking to save money, try shopping at a thrift store or making your own costume. For those who want to splurge, there are plenty of high-end costume stores that will have what you’re looking for.

What are the Most Popular Halloween Costumes?

The most popular Halloween costumes are those that are easy to put together and don’t require a lot of time or money. Some of the most popular costumes include witches, vampires, werewolves, zombies, pirates, princesses, superheroes, and cats. If you’re looking for something more unique, try shopping at a Halloween costume store or making your own costume.

The Best Halloween Costume Stores in Toronto

Now that you know what to expect in terms of cost and popularity, it’s time to start shopping for your costume! To help you out, we’ve compiled a list of the 11 best Halloween costume stores in Toronto.

1. Candy's Costume Shop

Whether you’re looking for the perfect costume for Halloween, a masquerade ball or just want to dress up for fun, Candy’s Costume Shop in Toronto is the place to go. They’ve been a popular destination for costumes, masquerade masks, wigs, makeup and accessories since 2008 and are committed to providing high-quality products and outstanding customer service. 

They have a wide selection of items to choose from and are always happy to help customers find what they’re looking for. So if you’re in the market for a costume or just want to browse their selection of masquerade masks, wigs and makeup, be sure to check out Candy’s Costume Shop. You won’t be disappointed!

Business Information:
685 Mt Pleasant Rd, Toronto, ON M4S 2N2, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“I have been on the hunt for a Star Trek costume as my Amazon order may not arrive in time. Was excited that they had one available! Great location with street parking. Friendly staff and good selection of costumes. Definitely will be back!”
“All of the staff are extremely nice and helpful! I came back multiple times, and each time a friendly face was there to give advice and answer all of my questions. This place definitely made my halloween so much better!”

2. Spirit Halloween

Spirit Halloween is the leading Halloween retailer globally, offering one-stop shopping for costumes, accessories, Halloween home decor, party products, and exclusive animatronics. While shopping with them, you’ll get your fill of fun and interactive events to enhance your entire Halloween shopping experience!

Additionally, they offer their customers an easy-to-navigate website which lists all of their items in simple categories, which you can browse through. They also offer other seasonal items that stay on their shelves for a short amount of time. So if you are looking for a highly itemized store to liven up your Halloween experience, visit Spirit Halloween and enter the mysterious world of spirits!

Business Information:
2231 St Clair Ave W, Toronto, ON M6N 1K5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“October is near! Heads up shoppers, they give a twenty percent off an individual item coupon per a transaction. So if you're going to buy a pricy item, either do a small transaction first or if they're generous enough ask if you can use the coupon right from the jump. Love Halloween.”
“I love this store so much! Was driving down at Clair and saw it was open. They have some great interactive decorations this year. The ones where you step on the circle on the floor? Bought some decorations this visit. Will be back later once the family decides on what to be!”

3. Party City

Party City is the ultimate destination for party supplies and accessories, making it the perfect place to shop for all your Halloween needs. While their physical locations are great for getting a feel for what they have to offer, their online store is where you’ll find their truly extensive inventory. 

Party City’s Halloween City is a one-stop-shop for everything from costumes and decorations to candy and games. And whether you’re shopping for a single item or looking to outfit an entire party, their team of party experts is always on hand to help. 

So whether you’re planning a spooky soiree or a fun-filled fiesta, Party City has everything you need to make it a success.

Business Information:
39 Orfus Rd, North York, ON L5L 5X8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“This is a nice and very large store. I love all the selection. The staff is good and knowledgeable. If I need help the staff is always readily available for questions. I will always drive to this Party City on Orfus drive.”
“Great costumer service!! I was looking for a Spiderman mask for a kid and I call them before going to the store, by phone someone checked physically the availability and reserve it for me to pick it up. Make a difference comparing with others stores. Congrats”

4. It's My Party

It’s My Party is the ultimate party destination, no matter what the occasion may be. They have everything you need to make any party a success, from balloons and streamers to masks and makeup. And if you’re looking for something truly unique, they also offer a range of exclusive party items that you won’t find anywhere else. 

Whether you’re planning a birthday celebration, an anniversary party, or simply a night out with friends, It’s My Party is the perfect place to start your preparations. And if Halloween is your favourite holiday, you’ll be glad to know that they have a whole section dedicated to Halloween, with everything from spooky decorations to scary costumes. 

So whatever your party needs may be, be sure to pay a visit to It’s My Party. You won’t be disappointed!

Business Information:
2208 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4C 1K3, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Small store.. if you don't see What you need.. ask.. There is tons you won't see right away. Staff is very helpful”
“Super amazing staff great party and hallowee n costumes and decorations”

5. Theatrics Plus

Theatrics Plus is the place to go for all your potential Halloween needs. From costumes and masks to masquerade items and wigs, this store has it all. Additionally, Theatrics Plus stocks party supplies to make sure your Halloween bash is one for the books. The store is small yet well-itemized, making it easy to find what you’re looking for quickly. 

The staff is also friendly and helpful, adding to the overall shopping experience. Plus, regular shoppers can enjoy discounts on items throughout the year. So whether you’re planning a Halloween party or simply looking for a costume, be sure to check out Theatrics Plus.

Business Information:
680 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4Y 2A6, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Ari was the best ever, I just came in to look but ari made it so fun and recommended contacts for our professional photo shoot that impacted the value of the whole production! Will definitely be back, hope she’s working when I am!! ❤️❤️❤️”
“What a relief. There's finally a store that has everything that one could want. The staff is truly amazing. They were all really helpful and made it really a great experience to shop here. This is the type of service you will never get at any big box store. Very fun and friendly people great job. Thank you for making my experience a wonderful one.”

6. Exile

At Exile, you’ll find more than just your average Halloween costume. They have a range of costumes for different seasons and holidays, so you can always find the perfect outfit no matter the occasion. 

But it’s not just about the costumes – they also sell accessories that will complete your look. From wigs to belts and everything in between, they have everything you need to make sure you’re dressing to impress. 

So whether you’re looking for the perfect Halloween costume or just an outfit for a special occasion, Exile is the place to shop.

Business Information:
60 Kensington Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2K1, Canada  

Customer Review Highlight:

“I absolutely love this place. The vibe, the workers, and the clothing are amazing. Everything in this store is very unique and tells a story. Steven was extremely helpful with helping me find the perfect pair of pants!! Lynn the owner was very friendly as-well. I can not wait to come back!!”
“I did some last minute Christmas shopping at Exile the other day and had a wonderful experience! Lynn (the owner) and her other employees were amazing in helping me select some pieces. Everything was well priced and she had a great selection of vintage pieces. Will definitely be coming back soon! This is a Kensington treasure 💞✨”

7. Maydwell Mascots Inc.

Maydwell Mascots is the perfect place to go for a custom-made, one-of-a-kind costume. Whether you need a mascot for your football team or a Halloween costume, they have got you covered. They have a wide selection of themed costumes to choose from, so you are sure to find the perfect one for your event.

 Keep in mind that they don’t sell ready-made costumes, but make one specifically for you and your idea, so it will take time and might cost a pretty penny. However, the end result will be well worth it! You will have a unique costume that nobody else will have, and that will make your event even more special. 

So if you are looking for something truly unique, be sure to check out Maydwell Mascots!

Business Information:
222 Islington Ave #10, Etobicoke, ON M8V 3W7, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“I had the opportunity to work with Maydwell Mascots to create my school's mascot. The team members were super understanding of our needs. They demonstrated such creativity and adaptability when designing a mascot that would represent our brand. Despite the COVID situation, they delivered the final product in a timely manner. The quality of our mascot is terrific and the design is outstanding. I would strongly recommend working with Maydwell Mascots for your future projects.”
“I enjoyed designing each detail of 2 mascots with Maydwell Mascots. Their team is supportive every step of the way, even making sure our mascots made it through customs. Great company and excellent quality.”

8. Tribal Rhythm Vintage

Tribal Rhythm is a vintage clothing store that offers a wide range of classical and stylish clothes. While most people think of Halloween as a time to buy pre-made costumes, Tribal Rhythm provides an alternative for those who want to be more creative with their outfits. By mixing and matching different items from the store, you can create your own unique costume. 

Best of all, most of the items at Tribal Rhythm are very affordable, so you won’t have to break the bank to get a great Halloween outfit. 

The next time you’re looking for a Halloween costume, be sure to check out Tribal Rhythm Vintage Clothing. You might just find everything you need to create the perfect ensemble.

Business Information:
248 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1Z7, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Oh how I love this store! The amazing vintage clothing organized by decade, and in impeccable condition. There are so many things I want that I cant come out of that store without a serious dent in my bank account. They also have some very cool jewellery, hats gloves etc that are new. You just gotta see for yourself!”
“Amazing staffs and items. I have been to different vintage shops and this is the only place I can get clothes from with decent prices. The clothing here is more era-specific (really vintage dresses) which can be hard to worn daily. But their pants section is amazing!!!! LOVEEEEE.”

9. Ian Drummond Collection Inc.

For over 25 years, Ian Drummond Collection has been amassing a clothing collection that would make any fashionista weak in the knees. With an extensive stock of vintage clothing, footwear, accessories, and textiles from the 20s to the present day, this store has something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a nobility-esque outfit or something more modern and fun, you’re sure to find it here. 

Not to mention, the prices are incredibly reasonable considering the quality of their garments. So whether you’re in the market for a new outfit or just want to browse through some eye-catching fashion, be sure to pay Ian Drummond Collection a visit!

Business Information:
222 Islington Ave #8, Etobicoke, ON M8V 3W7, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Ian and his collection are outstanding members of the industry. His decades of knowledge makes his collection absolutely comprehensive of vintage fashion and design, and he is always an utter pleasure to deal with when I visit several times each year,. I would, and frequently do, recommend him for any aspect whatsoever of working with vintage fashion.”
“The finest collection of period clothing wear rentals in the city!!!”

10. Thunder Thighs Costumes LTD

Thunder Thighs is a premier costume seller in Canada that offers its customers highly detailed, pre-made costumes that you can rent for yourself during a special event. They provide primarily movie-themed costumes that are great for various Halloween and other spooky-themed parties. 

You can roleplay as your favourite movie star or movie creature while also bringing enjoyment to the overall party experience. Overall this is a fantastic place to grab a great-looking costume that looks just like your favourite character/creature from a movie. 

If you want a specific outfit, you can look up the listings online ahead of time so you know exactly what will be available to you. There’s no need to go to some fancy costume store and spend an arm and a leg on something you’ll only wear once. Thunder Thighs has got you covered so you can have a blast at your next big party!

Business Information:
16 Busy St, Toronto, ON M4M 1N8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“This place is absolutely magical, it brings me back to my early childhood with all of the wonderful costumes on display. If you have a costume party to attend, go to thunder thighs costumes for some funky, cool, and exciting looks! They have all types of costumes from movie set to children's parties.”
“Best selection of costumes with multiple sizes of different styles and periods. Friendly and helpful staff. The only place to go.”ool, and exciting looks! They have all types of costumes from movie set to children's parties.”

11. Toronto and Woodbridge Costumes

Woodbridge Costumes has been a trusted source for high-quality costumes and Halloween accessories for over 15 years. They offer an extensive selection of both standard and unique items, all of which are sure to make your Halloween celebration a success. 

Whether you’re looking for something simple, like makeup and fake blood, or something more elaborate, like a mascot rental or a fantastic costume, Woodbridge Costumes has you covered. And their customer service is top-notch, so you can be sure that you’re getting the best possible value for your money. 

So if you’re looking for the perfect way to celebrate Halloween this year, be sure to check out Woodbridge Costumes! You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:   
Upstairs (side of building, 111 Regina Rd Unit 7, Woodbridge, ON L4L 8N5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Friendly service and super easy to place my order on the website. Some of the most elaborate costumes I’ve seen around! Amazing quality and rental prices were shockingly affordable, even before I used the discount. Definitely worth a visit!”
“This place is awesome! Really unique costume rentals for all ages and styles. I got a fundraiser costume here and had a great experience. Excellent customer service and welcoming store atmosphere. Will be back for my Halloween party!”

FAQs About Halloween Costumes

Some tips for choosing the right Halloween costume include considering your budget, the weather on Halloween night, and how much time you have to put your costume together. If you’re on a budget, try shopping at a thrift store or making your own costume. If you’re short on time, look for a costume that is easy to put together and doesn’t require a lot of accessories.
Some popular group Halloween costumes include the Addams Family, characters from The Wizard of Oz, Star Wars characters, Ghostbusters, and the Spice Girls. If you’re looking for something more unique, try coming up with your own group costume theme.
If you plan on wearing your Halloween costume more than once, you’ll need to take some steps to ensure that it stays in good condition. Some tips for storing your Halloween costume include hanging it up in a cool and dry place, wrapping it in acid-free tissue paper, and storing it in a breathable bag.
If your Halloween costume is made of natural fibers like cotton or wool, you can machine-wash it on a gentle cycle. If your costume is made of synthetic fibers like polyester or nylon, you should hand-wash it in cool water. You should also avoid washing your costume if it has any embellishments like sequins or beads, as these can become damaged in the wash.

Final Thoughts

This year you can be a slick movie actor, a flapper from the Roaring Twenties, or a mascot of your own creation. Whatever it is you’re looking for, these Toronto Halloween costume stores are sure to have something for everyone. This Halloween, you can go trick or treating or partying knowing you have one of the coolest costumes around.

You might also like...