The 12 Best Italian Bakeries in Toronto [2022]

Best Italian Bakeries in Toronto

If you’re a lover of Italian cuisine, then Toronto is the place to be! With its abundance of authentic Italian bakeries, there are endless delicious options to choose from. To help make your decision a little bit simpler, here are the 12 best Italian bakeries in the city. Here we chose the most popular and beloved bakeries, based on reviews, ratings, and selection.

From tried-and-true classics to newer and more innovative bakeries, there’s something here for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for some freshly baked bread, some decadent pastries, or sweet cannoli, one of these bakeries is sure to hit the spot! 

So next time you’re craving that just-like-mom’s-made taste of Italy, head on over to one of these fantastic bakeries and indulge your senses. You won’t regret it! 

If you wondering where else to grab yourself some more delicious baked treats in Toronto, check out our list of the best Chinese bakeries or the best Portuguese bakeries in Toronto.

Summary

What are the Most Popular Italian Baked Goods?

Italy has a rich history of baked goods, with some traditional favourites being bread, pastries, cakes, and cookies. Some of the most popular Italian baked goods include:

  • Pizzelle – A classic waffle-like cookie made from anise or vanilla flavouring.
  • Sfogliatelle – A shell-shaped pastry filled with ricotta or cream and often topped with candied fruit.
  • Panettone – A traditional yeast bread studded with dried or candied fruit, most commonly made around the holidays.
  • Biscotti – A classic Italian cookie that comes in many different flavours and is typically twice-baked for extra crispiness.

These are just a few of the many delicious Italian baked goods available, so be sure to visit your local bakery and pair it with your favourite cup of espresso for the ultimate Italian culinary experience!

The Best Italian Bakeries in Toronto

If you’re looking to sample some of the best Italian baked goods in Toronto, be sure to check out one of these top bakeries! With so many options to choose from, you’re sure to find something that hits the spot. Buon appetito!

1. Tre Mari Bakery

When you visit Tre Mari, the first thing that will catch your eye is how divided this place feels—there’s The Market where they sell all sorts of food and amenities from fresh bread to hot meals. And then if there’s time after shopping for dinner or an espresso break – go inside their cozy café! 

Tre Mari Bakery has been an institution in its neighbourhood since 1960. The family business is now being taken over by third-generation members that are dedicated to preserving what makes this bakery great while also adding something new for future generations of the residents of Toronto! 

When you order from their bakery, your cake will be fresh and made with ingredients that are prepared just how you want them. They offer many different flavours of cakes to choose from or they can work one, especially for you! 

The bakery’s family-run business and a strong history of catering to customers have made it one of the go-to places for foodies in this town. The homemade foods they provide can’t be beaten, plus you’ll feel like an old friend when their staff takes care during your visit because everyone here knows what good customer service is all about!

Business Information:

Website: tremaribakery.ca
Email: tremari@tremaribakery.ca
Telephone: +14166548960
Address: 1311 St Clair Ave W, Toronto, ON M6E 1C2, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Easily one of the best Italian cafes in town. They have great selection of sweets and pastries.I go here for my weekend espresso and grab the biscottis or other sweets.Hot table options too available. The service is great. And locals line up to enjoy their favourite coffee here “

Pros

  • Been in business for 60+ years
  • Serves various Italian pastries, breads & coffee, plus deli offerings

Cons

  • Usually pretty busy

2. Forno Cultura

Forno Cultura’s story is one of love, passion and pride. They are the third generation bakers who have been feeding their local community with true tastes from Italy using only natural ingredients for three generations now-and they never forget where it starts!

A taste so perfect you’ll hanker after its simplicity or crave depth beyond compare; these recipes will transport your mind back to a time when life was simple and happy. When you’re looking for a sweet treat, it’s hard to beat the selection at this little bakery. 

From biscotti and chocolate cookies alike they have an impressive variety of pastries that will satisfy any appetite – choose whatever you like! Not only do their baguettes come fresh from ovens near your location but there are other French goodies available in-store as well for you to grab on your way to work. 

So if you’re looking for some fresh baked goods, a friendly staff member to chat with and prices that don’t break the bank – then Forno Cultura is your go-to place!

Business Information:

Website: fornocultura.com
Email: focacceria@fornocultura.com
Telephone: +14166038305
Address: 609 King St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1M5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ OMG! Stumbled on this place for lunch! Mortadella sandwich on focaccia is to die for! Pistachio Biscotti was spot on. Truly a neighborhood gem for the folks that live near. “

Pros

  • Uses only the finest of natural ingredients and organic flours
  • Serves various Italian pastries, breads & coffee, plus deli offerings

Cons

  • Really busy on weekends

3. Sanremo Bakery

SanRemo Bakery has only one location, and until further notice, this is how they want it. The Bozzos family work daily at the bakery together; without them, there really isn’t a proper storefront for customers to buy their goods from anymore since both men contribute equally towards running such an establishment in past years where every dollar counts – literally! 

They have a wide range of treats to satisfy your tastebuds, from delicious cakes and danishes to amazing gelato, pastries, pies, bread and donuts! They also offer coffee for those who need their caffeine fix. The staff is super nice and they have an amazing selection of flavours you can choose from! 

It’s such a great spot that has pickups as well so if you hate waiting in line all day long you won’t be disappointed by pre-ordering online first before coming down yourself or getting delivered right to your doorstep too if desired. 

The prices are also unbeatable and the quality is amazing so if you`re looking for a perfect spot to satisfy your tasty sweet treats needs – look no further!

Business Information:

Website: sanremobakery.com
Email: orders@sanremobakery.com
Telephone: +14162552808
Address: 374 Royal York Rd, Etobicoke, ON M8Y 2R3, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Best damn bakery I’ve been to in Toronto.Their donuts are the best! Around 2.50 for each and cheaper in half a dozen and more. Not pictured are their delicious sandwiches and even their coffee though cheap is not cheap in taste. I want to come here every weekend! Only downside was their Red Velvet cupcake but they have so much choice you can find something that suits you! “

Pros

  • Family-owned bakery serving the GTA for 50+ years
  • Italian recipes and methods with a modern twist

Cons

  • Closed on Mondays

4. Rustic Bakery

The Rustic Bakery has been a Toronto favourite for years, with its Calabrese bread and buns that are impossible to resist. You’ll find specialty food to suit any taste – from traditional varieties of bread, all the way up to custom wedding cakes made just how you want them, plus their hot table is always stocked with tempting dessert options like gelato machines that will make any sweet tooth sing joyful tunes!

In addition, they have excellent catering services so no matter what size event takes place today – they always have your back. They take great pride in the quality and freshness of their products. 

From Toronto to Niagara, people across Ontario come here for a taste experience that they won’t forget! The staff here are also friendly and overall it’s a very welcoming environment with plenty going on inside!

Business Information:

Website: therusticbakery.ca
Email: rusticbakerycatering@gmail.com
Telephone: +14162451919
Address: 318 Rustic Rd, North York, ON M6L 1W5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ What a hidden gem. Delicious everything! So many yummy pastries and the coffee, SO GOOD! And so well stocked with everything pantry related and beyond. We’ll stop by again whenever we’re in the neighborhood again. “

Pros

  • One of Toronto’s finest bakeries for Calabrese bread
  • Offer catering for events

Cons

  • Usually quite busy

5. Sud Forno

Sud Forno is an authentic Italian bakery in the heart of downtown Toronto. Their selection of Italian specialty pizzas will make your mouth water just by looking at them! Alongside these delicious pizza slices are other items such as prepared sandwiches and salads that you can take out or eat in-house at Sud Forno – there’s something for everyone here including those who prefer fresh baked goods instead of frozen meals on busy days. 

They use their own mother yeast to make sure that the finished loaves are traditional and delicious – unlike any they’d ever tasted outside of Italy. With high-quality grains, flours imported from a third-generation family-run mill in the Marche region as well as using only natural methods for fermentation gives them bread so good you’ll think it came straight off an Italian table! 

This place has everything you’ve ever wanted – their baked goods are top-notch as well as their coffee! And seeing how they make them right in front of you is just incredible: it really brings out the best qualities in each recipe so every bite tastes better than before. 

So if you’re looking for an authentic Italian bakery that will bring back memories of your favourite pastries and coffee shops from home, then look no further!

Business Information:

Website: terroni.com
Email: info@terroni.com
Telephone: +14165047667
Address: 716 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Take your espressino and lemon sugar cookies, have a seat while enjoying Queen West 🙂 One of my favorite places in Toronto. As soon as you open the door, you smell the deserts. Great quality, great ambiance. “

Pros

  • Daily selection of sliced pizza, prepared sandwiches and salads along with pastries and gelato
  • Their bread is made from high-quality grains and flours that they import from a third-generation family run mill in the Marche region

Cons

  • A few complaints about customer service

6. Mattachioni

Mattachioni is the perfect place to get your hands on some of Italy’s most famous pastries. The pastries here are second to none, and you’ll find it difficult not to be tempted by any of their delicious treats! 

They have an extensive variety of apristomato, panini and more. They also have a wide variety of delicious pizzas, from the basic to surprising options with your favourite toppings. Mattachioni is a local favourite for good reason. The food here tastes like the real deal and you’ll leave satisfied without feeling too heavy or full from all your calories (unlike some other places). 

Plus their service makes it easy to spend more time dining in than going elsewhere!  The staff members always seem friendly, and are both professional while still being courteous towards your needs as a customer- they definitely know what good customer service is!

Business Information:

Website: mattachioni.com
Email: info.mattachioni@gmail.com
Telephone: +14165191010
Address: 1617 Dupont St, Toronto, ON M6P 3S8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Shared burrata salad and margarita pizza with 2 others. Everything was fresh and delicious. The toasted bread that came with the salad was drizzled in one of the best olive oils I've tasted. We asked for a couple more pieces to soak up every bit and they generously provided without hesitation. A definite must if you're in the area! “

Pros

  • Opened everyday
  • Large menu

Cons

  • A few complaints about customer service

7. Messina Bakery

Messina Bakery is the ultimate destination for all your favourite baking needs. With a wide variety of fresh pastries and desserts that are made with natural ingredients only – you won’t be disappointed! 

Messina Bakery is a family-owned business that has been around since 1970. They pride themselves on the fact that they don’t use any preservatives or artificial ingredients in their products, instead of relying only upon pride for added flavour! 

Their Sicilian cannoli are world-famous – so much so people from all over come here just because of them (and also get some cake). They offer a variety of delicious, fresh baked goods to satisfy your cravings. Choose from bread and pastries in addition to hot table options like pies or strudel!  

The food is always fresh and delicious, they make you feel so welcome in their restaurant even if it’s your first time visiting. From the moment you walk through those doors until you finish eating your meal – it really feels like an authentic Italian experience somewhere not too far away from home!

Business Information:

Website: messinabakery.com
Email: info@messinabakery.com
Telephone: +14167622496
Address: 19 Scarlett Rd, York, ON M6N 4J5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ This is the best Italian bakery in Toronto!!!! Their cheesecake is so flakey and moist & always reminds me of the episode of ‘Friends’(the tv show) where Rachel & Chandler ate their neighbors cheesecake. (If you’re a friend's fan, you just know) excellent customer service! Helpful. Kind. Good atmosphere. Thank you!!!! “

Pros

  • Serves great coffee
  • Also sells Italian grocery items

Cons

  • Can get quite busy in the afternoon

8. Tre Rose Bakery

Tre Rose Bakery has been a Rexdale and Etobicoke favourite for over 25 years. They’ve got your neighbourhood bread needs covered with delicious memories that will make you come back time after time! 

You can get a fresh, hot loaf of artisan bread every day. With a variety to choose from including large loaves and traditional buns as well as Italian style fraughtlla’s & cheese infused baguettes, you’ll be sure to find something for everyone on this list! 

Their classic Italian and european-style sandwiches will delight your senses with their fresh ingredients, while their delicious meals cater to any event. They also offer a wide variety of meats, fish, and pasta as well as lasagnas or pizza that are sure to not only satisfy you but also impress those around them! 

The staff here are so nice. They’re always asking if everything’s alright which makes them stand out from other restaurants where customer service isn’t a priority – so don’t hesitate to visit them today!

Business Information:

Website: trerosebakery.ca
Email: trerosebakery@hotmail.com
Telephone: +14167475343
Address: 2098 Kipling Ave, Etobicoke, ON M9W 4K5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Grew up in the area. This is one of the staples of the community.While it has definitely grown and changed over the last couple decades. It still has amazing food and some of the original staff tell it like it is!Great place for some food, baked goods and everything in between. Very safe and friendly bakery in Rexdale. “

Pros

  • Known for its deli fare & hot lunches, plus pastries & special-occasion cakes
  • Been in business since 1989

Cons

  • A few complaints about customer service

9. Amico Bakery

Amico Chef Bakery wants to provide you with a taste of Italy in every bite. They offer their customers 100% authentic Italian culinary tradition, and they’re confident that once you experience it for yourself- there’s no going back! 

They offer a variety of Italian-style dishes to satisfy your hunger. You can enjoy an espresso or cornetto with crema inside for breakfast, lunch at any time you’re in need and even have some pizza slices on the way home.

If you’re looking to bring the flavours of Italy home, they also have a mouthwatering selection that will make all those memories come alive. From cookies & cakes galore in either sweet or savoury options – there’s something here sure worth checking out before it passes by too quickly. 

All of their products are made with love and care by creative chefs who want nothing more than to make sure you get exactly what’s on your mind when it comes time to try something new. They use old-fashioned techniques to ensure an authentic product, and they’re proud of the fact that their customers can taste it!

Business Information:

Website: amicochef.com
Email: info@amicochef.com
Telephone: +14169012729
Address: 2889 Dufferin St, North York, ON M6B 3S7, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Amazing Bakery which competes with the best of them in Toronto. They have some of the best pizza ever and the offerings have been even better since their expansion. Catered my small micro wedding as well and were a pleasure to deal with. “

Pros

  • Offers 100% authentic Italian culinary tradition
  • Also offers prepared frozen meals

Cons

  • A few complaints about their custom cakes

10. Francesca Italian Bakery & Delicatessen

Francesca Bakery was built on creating excellent baked goods, while always making sure they are fresh and made with superior products sourced from all over the world. They believe that a tasty treat can be an elegant addition to your table or pocket-friendly satisfaction when you need it most. 

The pastries, bread and cakes at your new favourite bakery will take you back to a time when life was simpler. You can also try some of your favourites like pasta, calamari, chicken cutlets or potato wedges with all the trimmings! 

Francesca Bakery has the best team in town when it comes to baking cakes, and they also offer custom design orders – you can make your friend’s birthday memorable with their amazing skills. The service at this restaurant is friendly and the prices are reasonable, so you won’t break the bank eating there! 

Plus their delicious cuisine will make your mouth water with joy from all of those tempting flavours combined together on one plate – it truly sounds like a blissful experience!

Business Information:

Website: francescabakery.com
Telephone: +14162991174
Address: 2 Invergordon Ave, Scarborough, ON M1S 2Y8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ This bakery has become a family favourite for us! We've gotten deli meats, sweet canolis and deliciously loaded sandwiches from them and everything is fantastic! Their delicious rates are reasonable and one sandwich can feed two! Great service as well! “

Pros

  • Hot table open 7 days a week
  • Been in business for 20+ years

Cons

  • Closes early at 4 pm

11. Lamanna's Bakery

Lamanna’s Bakery pride themselves on the quality and taste that has continuity from grandmothers’ kitchens through generations to today’s kitchen windows across America where new ideas are mixed with authentic family recipes. This means you can get all sorts of goodies at their bakery: lasagna, pizza, lobster tails, cannoli, gelato – the options really never end here. 

They also offer catering so whether you’re hosting an office party, a wedding reception or celebrating with family and friends at home – they have the perfect food selection to suit any occasion. They will bring your event together with their range of tasty treats that are sure not only delightfully impressive but also super quick! 

The bakery itself is very clean and well organized. It’s clear that the staff are well-trained because they provide excellent customer service. You can order ahead or pick up your items at this location, so if you want to try something new – look no further!

Business Information:

Website: lamannabakery.com
Email: lamannabakery@bell.net
Telephone: +14162872020
Address: 6758 Kingston Rd, Scarborough, ON M1B 1G8, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ Lamanna’s bakery has everything from hot food to desserts. I’ve been here a couple of times and there was always a line up. Their baked goods and desserts are fresh and fairly priced.We placed an order for their giant pizza slice and it was really well made. Everyone enjoyed it and it was shared among 5 people. You can call in and order before with the toppings you want. Highly recommend it if you want to surprise someone for their bday! “

Pros

  • Great selection of traditional Italian sweets
  • Also offer catering

Cons

  • Closed on weekends

12. Nino D’Aversa Bakery

Nino D’Aversa Bakery has been baking fine bread and baked goods in the GTA since 1969. From sweet treats like gelato and cake for those with an even hungrier appetite to full meals fit for any occasion, there’s no shortage of quality food here! 

They are proud to provide their baked goods through many of the finest grocery stores and commercial establishments in Greater Toronto, giving you a simple way to accent homemade meals with fine Italian bread. They don’t cut corners when it comes to quality, which is why they always use only fresh ingredients for your satisfaction. 

For over four decades now their reputation has been building here in Toronto – with people coming back time and again because they know what good means! The first thing you notice as soon as you walk into this place is the warm and inviting atmosphere. The people working here are friendly without being overbearing or asking anything but your order–and it’s all perfectly cooked too!

Business Information:

Website: ninodaversa.com
Telephone: +14166383271
Address: 1 Toro Rd, North York, ON M3J 2A4, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“ I've been a customer here for years, they always have a great selection. Lovely place with a wonderful smell of bread and coffee. Placed an order for a tiramisu cake and it came out great. Super fragrant and even better tasting! Gelato is also always very nice here. “

Pros

  • Multiple locations throughout the GTA
  • Very nice selection of pastries

Cons

  • Can get quite busy in the afternoon

FAQs About Italian Bakeries

Most bakeries will display their fresh baked goods in the front window so that customers can easily see what is available. Some bakeries may also offer special deals, such as “buy one, get one free” offers, when they have extra baked goods that need to be sold before they go stale.
Italian bread is best stored at room temperature in a dry, cool place. It can also be wrapped in a clean towel or placed in a bread box to keep it fresh for longer. If you plan on storing the bread for more than a few days, it is best to freeze it to prevent it from going moldy.
Typically, Italian bread will last for about 2-3 days when stored at room temperature in a dry, cool place. Bread that has been frozen can last for up to 6 months.
Italian bread typically has a higher ratio of water to flour, which gives it a softer texture. It also often contains olive oil, which adds flavour and moisture. Additionally, Italian bread is usually made with a starter known as biga or poolish, which helps to develop the bread’s flavour and texture.

Final Thoughts

There you have it! These are the 12 best Italian bakeries in Toronto. Be sure to check them out the next time you’re in the mood for some truly authentic and delicious Italian baked goods. From classic cookies and cakes to fresh bread and pastries, there’s something here for everyone to enjoy. Buon appetite!

You might also like...

Toronto Blogs - Toronto Local News

Business Listings

Terms & Conditions

Privacy Policy

Sitemap