The Best 12 Italian Restaurants in Toronto [2023]

Best 12 Italian Restaurants in Toronto

Toronto’s Italian community has significantly impacted the city’s food culture since the mid-century era. As the city’s demographics change, Italian-Canadian food culture has evolved and helped define Toronto’s food identity. Throughout Toronto’s neighbourhoods, there are many incredible Italian restaurants to choose from.

Discover our picks for Toronto’s best Italian restaurants, offering diverse cuisine, ambiance, and affordability. From traditional trattorias to modernized eateries, there’s an Italian restaurant to suit every taste and budget. For more recommendations, explore our list of the best Korean restaurants or the best Mexican restaurants in Toronto.

Summary

What are the Most Popular Italian Dishes to Order?

The delights of Italian cuisine are vast and varied with ingredients like fresh meats, bread, pasta, vegetables, herbs and other delectables. In Toronto, you’re guaranteed to find something to satisfy your taste preferences. Indulge in Mediterranean flavours with these classic, popular must-try Italian dishes.

Spaghetti Bolognese: Savory ground beef in a rich tomato sauce with herbs.

Margherita Pizza: A classic combination of tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil.

Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken smothered in tomato sauce and melted mozzarella, served with spaghetti.

Fettuccine Alfredo: Creamy ribbons of pasta coated in a delectable sauce of butter, cream, and Parmesan cheese.

And don’t forget about the wine! Italy boasts some of the world’s finest wines, so ensure you savour a bottle (or two) with your meal as recommended by your server.

The Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto

Now that you have an idea of what to order, check out our top picks for the best Italian restaurants in Toronto.

1. Grazie Ristorante

Grazie Ristorante

If you’re craving delectable Italian cuisine, make Grazie Ristorante your go-to spot. This restaurant has built a massive following of loyal customers over the years, and it’s easy to see why.

Their menu showcases all the classic Italian dishes you love—like bruschetta, gnocchi, and linguine marinara—prepared with utmost care using fresh ingredients. 

Alongside the fantastic food, Grazie offers impeccable service. From the moment you step through the door until you leave, you’ll be treated like royalty. The cozy atmosphere creates the perfect setting for a top-notch romantic night out or a fun evening with friends.

Business Information:

2373 Yonge Street, Toronto, ON M4P 2C8
416-488-0822
grazie.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“What a fantastic experience! Went here for lunch with my friend. Got the Giovanni pizza and spicy oil. Had a Caesar salad to start. The food here is so good! I can’t recommend it enough. The place is cozy and warm. But also the service is always so good! The people are kind and nice and attentive. If I could give more stars I would!”

Pros

Cons

2. Terroni

Terroni
Yelp/Min C.

Terroni is always bustling with customers, regardless of the time you visit, and there’s a good reason for it— their Italian cuisine is among the best in the city. They pride themselves on making fresh, in-house pasta and serving wood-fired, crispy pizzas.

If you’re seeking something beyond the usual options, Terroni also offers delightful dishes like spaghetti alla chitarra, duck confit, and braised octopus.

The inviting atmosphere and superb service at Terroni make it an ideal choice for a gathering with friends or family.

Business Information:

57 Adelaide Street East, Toronto, ON M5C 1K6
416-203-3093
terroni.com

Customer Review Highlights:

"I had dinner with a friend at Terroni and it was a great dining experience. We ordered the fried calamari and mushroom appetizers to start with, which were quite good. The Tuna main course was good as well, but I was particularly impressed by the duck Ravioli, which was absolutely delicious. The wine and other alcoholic beverage selections were great, and the servers were all very nice and helpful. Highly recommended."

Pros

Cons

3. Trattoria Nervosa

Trattoria Nervosa
Yelp/Min C.

Trattoria Nervosa is the perfect spot for a romantic Italian dinner in the heart of Yorkville. The rustic decor and cozy atmosphere make it feel like you’re dining in a little trattoria in the Italian countryside.

The food here is incredible, with mouth-watering dishes like truffle funghi pasta, grilled octopus, and capellini pasta. The service is great, and they even have a lovely patio for al fresco dining on warm summer nights.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian dining experience, Trattoria Nervosa is the perfect place. Buon appetito!

Business Information:

75 Yorkville Avenue, Toronto, ON M5R 1B8 
416-961-4642
eatnervosa.com

Customer Review Highlights:

“I had great experience having dinner at Terroni! The vibe of the restaurant was perfect. Specious with rustic decorations and a nice fire place. Our waiter did a great job and made us feel like guests in a friend’s house. Wine and food were perfect to high standards. Fresh pastas! Delicious desserts.”

Pros

Cons

4. Piano Piano

Piano Piano
Yelp/Ada C.

Piano Piano Restaurant is a cozy Italian eatery located near Harbord & Spadina. The restaurant boasts an amazing patio, making it the perfect spot for summertime dining. Their menu includes a variety of delicious items, such as Parma Crudo, Mushroom Cavatelli, Bistecca al Pepe, and lots of other pasta dishes and pizzas.

The service at Piano Piano is top-notch, ensuring that you’ll have an amazing night out filled with great food and drinks. If you’re looking for a new spot to try, definitely add Piano Piano Restaurant to your list. You won’t be disappointed!

Business Information:

88 Harbord Street, Toronto, ON M5S 1G5
416-929-7788
pianopianotherestaurant.com

Customer Review Highlights:

“Visited Piano Piano with a few friends one Thursday evening - we had reservations in advance so we were seated right away. Staff was really friendly, service was solid. Atmosphere was very welcoming, aesthetics were really nice. Ordered a fun guy pizza (vegetarian) to split which was really delicious as well as ordering the egg yolk ravioli which was really good and had a really nice presentation on the plate - wish there was a 3rd ravioli though (only comes with 2). Price $$-$$$. Definitely recommend checking this place out if you’re in the Spadina area!”

Pros

Cons

5. La Vecchia Restaurant

La Vecchia Restaurant
Yelp/Queenie C.

La Vecchia is the perfect place to take your date for a romantic dinner. The ambience is cozy and charming, with black-and-white photos evoking the past. The pasta options here are out of this world, and the wine list is impressive.

You can’t go wrong with classic dishes like gnocchi ai quattro formaggi or carpaccio di manzo. And for something lighter, the capellini is a delicate delight. 

Whether you’re looking for a special occasion spot or a casual eatery for amazing Italian cuisine, La Vecchia is the place for you.

Business Information:

2405 Yonge Street, Unit A, Toronto, ON M4P 2E7
416-489-0630
lavecchia.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“I have been to a few Italian restaurants both in and out of the country, and I have to say this is somewhere in my top three. Our server was Alex, and his service was amazing. Helpful on the menu. attentive, and made sure me and my wife were taken care of throughout the meal. I highly recommend the four cheese Gnocchi, though their specials for the day are equally amazing. If you have room, the desserts are pretty decadent. Plan on going again.”

Pros

Cons

6. Figo Toronto

Figo Toronto
Yelp/Chris A.

Figo offers stunningly presented and delicious dishes in an open and airy space with impressive views of the open kitchen. Pasta lovers will delight in the diverse menu, while others can enjoy options like calamari fritti, bucatini, and mouth watering pizzas. Don’t miss the opportunity to try their fantastic wine selection.

Whether it’s a romantic dinner or a special occasion with loved ones, Figo is the perfect spot. Though the dishes may be small, their flavours make a big impact and treat your senses to an unforgettable experience!

Business Information:

295 Adelaide St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1P7
+16477483446
figotoronto.com

Customer Review Highlights:

“Had a great experience here. Food was extremely delicious! I highly recommend getting exactly what I ordered because they were all so good! For appy get the Zucchini Fritti paired with the Polpette! The zucchini fritti goes from a 10 to a 15 when you dip it in that meatball sauce. Then get the Bucatini Al Ragu they are thick noodles cooked to perfection and then honestly any pizza you want to get I’m 100% sure will be a banger. I got the Tartufo Bianca and it was great! Will definitely visit again! Cocktails were meh. Get wine.”

Pros

Cons

7. Buca Osteria & Bar

Buca Osteria & Bar
Yelp/Gabriel A.

Buca Osteria & Bar on Scollard is a high-end Italian restaurant that offers a modern, bright, and warm atmosphere. The restaurant is located in the Four Seasons courtyard, and the entrance is via Yorkville Avenue on the south side.

The restaurant offers a broad selection of seafood dishes, including house-made salumi di mare and fresh branzino, in addition to beloved pastas and pizzas.

The service is attentive, and the dining experience is slow-paced. Customers are recommended to take their coat off and enjoy the ambiance.

Business Information:

53 Scollard Street, Toronto, ON M5R 0A1 (front entrance on Yorkville Avenue via the Four Seasons Courtyard)
416-962-2822
buca.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“Amazing experience at Buca for our very first visit! Everything we ordered was absolutely fantastic and exceeded our expectations (focaccia bread, olives, short rib pizza, wagyu steak). The highlight was the wagyu steak that just melted when we took a bite, and it blew us away. It was probably one of the best steaks I’ve ever had in my life! Restaurant inside has a really nice ambiance and it wasn’t too loud inside. Definitely will be going back!”

Pros

Cons

8. Blu Ristorante

Blu Ristorante
Yelp/Alfredo R.

Blu Ristorante has a dark and quiet interior, creating a cozy and intimate atmosphere. The restaurant is located in the heart of Yorkville, and it offers a high end dining experience

The menu features an impressive selection of cocktails and authentic classic Italian cuisine, including antipasti, insalata, pasta, secondi, sides, and dessert. The beef carpaccio and the seafood pasta are some of the most highly recommended dishes.

The service is passionate and attentive, and the restaurant offers live ambient music on Fridays and Saturdays. Blu Ristorante is also available for private lunches and events.

Business Information:

90 Avenue Road, Toronto, ON M5R 2H2
416-921-1471
bluristorante.com

Customer Review Highlights:

“I’ve been to Blu on two separate occasions and both were spectacular! The food is always delicious and if it’s not cooked to perfection, the team is always extremely receptive and do what they can to make things right. Both times, our servers were extremely personable and attentive. It’s become a go-to place amongst my friends and I highly recommend going if you’ve never been!”

Pros

Cons

9. Ristorante Sotto Sotto

Ristorante Sotto Sotto

Ristorante Sotto Sotto, renowned for its upscale ambiance and culinary excellence, has garnered numerous awards and accolades. Its reputation has made it a popular destination for celebrities who are drawn to its intimate, dimly-lit tables.

The menu features authentic Italian cuisine, including antipasti, pasta, seafood, and meat dishes. The restaurant is known for its signature dish, the truffle pasta, and has an extensive wine list with a focus on Italian wines.

The service is attentive and professional, and reservations are recommended due to the restaurant’s popularity.

Business Information:

120 Avenue Road, Toronto, ON M5R 2H4
416-962-0011
sottosotto.ca/toronto

Customer Review Highlights:

“One of the best places in Toronto! The food here is quiet delicious. Got the veal and it was quiet tasty with the sauce. The strawberry tiramisu is a must try and it was great. The prices here are quiet reasonable and the staff here are super friendly. Will surely be back.”

Pros

Cons

10. Pizza e Pazzi

Pizza e Pazzi

Pizza e Pazzi is a welcoming, family-run establishment offering a casual ambiance. Known for its authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and homemade pasta, the restaurant presents a menu teeming with delectable pizza options and a variety of pasta dishes.

In addition to their renowned pizza, Pizza e Pazzi serves salads, antipasti, and desserts. The restaurant’s spaghetti carbonara and rigatoni alla vodka are particularly popular.

Praised for its fresh fare and friendly service, Pizza e Pazzi has earned a stellar reputation in Toronto and has been voted the city’s best pizza.

Business Information:

1182 St. Clair Avenue West, Toronto, ON M6E 1B4
416-651-9999
pizzaepazzi.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“Me and my girlfriend came today and honestly had the best service I’ve ever experienced from Roberto, every dish we asked about he knew how to explain in perfect detail and gave the best recommendations, the food he suggested was so good we will 1000% be back but only if Roberto is our server! He was kind, caring and attentive, it felt like we were being served by a lifetime friend!”

Pros

Cons

11. Enoteca Sociale

Enoteca Sociale
Yelp/Claudia C.

Enoteca Sociale is a cozy, intimate restaurant that’s become a mainstay for Italian cuisine in Toronto. Its food philosophy is built on making simple and honest food.

The menu features traditional Italian dishes, including pasta, pizza, and antipasti, with a focus on seasonal ingredients. Its most requested dishes include the house-made pasta, burrata salad, and fave e cicoria. Enoteca Sociale also offers a variety of wines and cheeses.

The restaurant is highly regarded and has received accolades from Michelin Guide. The service is attentive and professional, and the restaurant offers a four-seat, reservation-only chef’s bar.

Business Information:

1288 Dundas Street West, Toronto, ON M6J 1X7
416-534-1200
sociale.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“I was just driving by, and noticed the restaurant on my way home.. so I just got some take out... So while I was waiting for my food, I was paying attention to what was going on.. And here's what I can tell u... the atmosphere was charming, the environment.. relaxed, and the attentiveness from the staff to their patrons was obvious!, I will definitely go there to eat sometime soon! (quick post note...the appetizer I got was amazing! )”

Pros

Cons

12. Giulietta

Giulietta
Yelp/Steph L.

Giulietta boasts a sleek, cream-coloured interior by renowned architect Guido Costantinothat creates an inviting atmosphere to savour authentic Italian dishes. The restaurant focuses on featuring fresh, seasonal recipes, which makes sharing plates highlight. Notable dishes include the Margherita pizza, Cacio e Pepe pasta, octopus with potatoes and salsa verde, ricotta gnocchi with tomato and basil, and grilled ribeye steak with salsa verde.

The restaurant’s attentive and friendly service has earned praise from customers and the Michelin Guide recognition. It’s the perfect venue for a delightful engagement, anniversary or celebration dinner.

Business Information:

972 College Street, Toronto, ON M6H 1A5
416-964-0606
giu.ca

Customer Review Highlights:

“Restored my faith in the Toronto dining scene after so many abysmal experiences lately. These guys know what they’re doing from the food to service to ambiance. Dishes from start to finish were excellent. Nailed the seafood which is extremely rare in Ontario!!”

Pros

Cons

FAQs about Italian Restaurants in Toronto

Italian fare is made of fresh ingredients like fish, shellfish, and vegetables—tomatoes, garlic, mushrooms, spinach—and features pasta and bread. Common herbs include basil, sage, and oregano. Desserts comprise crunchy biscotti, creamy tiramisu, icy gelato and other complex flavour and texture combinations.
Yes, most Italian restaurants accept reservations. Call directly or book through their website.
Typically, yes. Vegetarians can opt for risotto with mushrooms. Vegans can savour eggplant parmigiana. Meat-eaters can enjoy chicken marsala or linguine alle vongole. Inform your server of any dietary restrictions or allergies. It’s best to call ahead to confirm.
Pair red wine like Chianti, Barolo or Montepulciano d’Abruzzo with rich pastas and meats. For white, try Pinot Grigio or Prosecco with appetizers, seafood, light pastas and desserts.
“Al dente” means that the pasta is cooked to be firm to the bite.

Final Thoughts

Toronto’s Italian restaurants deliver a range of dining experiences and tastes—from fine dining establishments to casual eateries. The city’s vibrant culinary landscape showcases the rich flavours and traditions of Italian cuisine, making dining out a truly enjoyable experience.

Prioritize visiting our 12 best Italian restaurants in Toronto when searching for a fantastic Italian restaurant, You’ll be thoroughly satisfied. Share your memorable local Italian restaurant experience in the comments!

Picture of Sarita Wiggan

Sarita Wiggan

Sarita Wiggan is a Toronto-raised creative with a deep appreciation for the city’s diverse cultural communities. Learn More About Sarita Wiggan

You might also like...

The 9 Best Osteopaths in Toronto

Need relief from pain and better mobility? Osteopaths specialize in treating neuromusculoskeletal disorders with techniques like massage, spinal manipulation, and...

Read More