The Best 12 Italian Restaurants in Toronto

Toronto is home to tons of amazing Italian restaurants. There are many different options for you to choose from such as pizza, pasta or other delectable treats. No matter what you are craving, Toronto has got you covered.
It might be hard to decide which one to go with, which is why we have put together a list of the best 12 Italian restaurants in Toronto.

Summary

12. Giulietta

Giulietta
Yelp/Steph L.
This authentic Italian restaurant is located right in the heart of downtown Toronto, which means that it’s perfect for getting some great food while you are also doing some shopping.
The menu has an amazing selection of pizzas and pastas, but what really stands out at this restaurant is its wine list, there are lots of options for white, red and even sparkling wines.
One dish that shouldn’t be missed here is the grilled octopus with cannellini beans. The octopus is cooked to perfection and it works perfectly with the beans.
It is a great place for lunch or dinner with friends or family during the warmer months because it has large windows that open all the way up which creates an open concept feel. This restaurant has both inside and outside spaces for people to enjoy their meal.

Address: 972 College St, Toronto
Phone: (416) 964-0606

Customer Review:

"Great place to enjoy Italian dining in the upscale side. Liz took care of our dinner and recommended great food to enjoy. Atmosphere and service were excellent. We enjoyed the octopus, Giulietta pizza, risotto and pazza scallops. I'd come back to enjoy other plates that will be recommended."
- Jose P

11. Enoteca Sociale

Enoteca Sociale
Yelp/Claudia C.
Enoteca Sociale, a funky spot in Toronto that offers Italian small plates, housemade pasta, wines and more. This casual restaurant has an amazing patio on the outside and has a great vibe on the inside.
This spot has some of the best pasta and salami dishes in Toronto, including spaghetti cacio e pepe & amatriciana.
The dishes at Enoteca Sociale are small but they will leave you wanting more, which is why you should definitely order multiple things to share with your friends or family. It’s perfect for an intimate dinner for two or for a larger group.

Address: 1288 Dundas St W, Toronto
Phone: (416) 534-1200

Customer Review:

"How can I say, it was a gift to discover this restaurant for my last dinner here. Even the meat lovers will take vegetarian options! Staff is welcoming, and the guy at the bar is from Italy so he knows wines well. Would recommend & would go everytime I come in the city."
- Sandrine

10. Pizza e Pazzi

Pizza e Pazzi
Pizza e Pazzi is located by Dufferin St. & St.Clair Ave W. This Italian restaurant has a great atmosphere and an amazing staff. The menu includes items like calamari, fritti, lobster tail and more. However, when you visit this restaurant you need to order a pizza, it is amazing and worth every bite.
It really doesn’t matter what type of pizza you get here because they are all equally delicious. You will be blown away by the number of pizza options you have.
This spot is perfect for dinner or brunch on the weekend, plus they have a great patio that is perfect for warmer months.

Address: 1182 St Clair Ave W, Toronto
Phone: (416) 651-9999

Customer Review:

"This place is amazing! The staff are extremely friendly and accommodating. We especially loved Jorge, the manager, and Roberto our server. Jorge and Roberto went out of their way to make our experience memorable. I highly recommend. On top of the excellent service, the food was delicious."
- Jennifer Earle

9. Ristorante Sotto Sotto

Ristorante Sotto Sotto
Ristorante Sotto Sotto is located by Avenue Rd & Davenport Rd. This Italian restaurant is a great spot for people that are looking to have a nice intimate dinner with their friends or family. The service here is outstanding and the food will not disappoint you at all, one of its most popular dishes being the grilled octopus which is served on a bed of beans and radicchio which is simply divine.
This restaurant has a great selection of wines and pasta that will delight your taste buds. This spot also does take away orders as well as reservations, so there’s no reason not to try it out!
You know this place is good, as many celebrities dine here.

Address: 120 Avenue Rd, Toronto
Phone: (416) 962-0011

Customer Review:

"I must say and truly, this is the first review I've ever posted in my entire life but Sotto Sotto is most definitely deserving of one. I brought my family to celebrate my sons graduation to "Sotto Sotto", the famous favorite restaurant of a supposed musician according my my son. I have to say I can see why. The steak is possibly one of the best if not the best steak I've ever had, top 3 for sure. The cheesecake was by far the best. My family also really enjoyed their meal and our waiter Al was very welcoming and helpful in making our experience a great one. Thank you for the amazing experience. 10/10!!!"
- John Velez

8. Blu Ristorante

Blu Ristorante
Yelp/Alfredo R.
Blu Ristorante is located in the heart of Yorkville. This is a romantic spot for any couple out there to enjoy a nice meal.
The menu at this restaurant includes items like roasted Atlantic salmon, wood-grilled ribeye and truffle mushroom risotto.
The wine selection at Blu is impressive as well, there are lots of options depending on what you’re in the mood for. This restaurant has an amazing intimate lighting setup which creates the perfect atmosphere.

Address: 90 Avenue Rd, Toronto
Phone: (416) 921-1471

Customer Review:

"I’ve been to Blu on two separate occasions and both were spectacular! The food is always delicious and if it’s not cooked to perfection, the team is always extremely receptive and do what they can to make things right. Both times, our servers were extremely personable and attentive. It’s become a go-to place amongst my friends and I highly recommend going if you’ve never been! Note, the restaurant is often booked full so make sure you plan ahead and make reservations."
- Christine Bui

7. Buca Osteria & Bar

Buca Osteria & Bar
Yelp/Gabriel A.
Buca Osteria & Bar is a posh Italian restaurant located on King Street. This restaurant has a great selection of cocktails and wines. The menu features items like gnocchi al tartufo bianco, salva cremasco, polpo, and more.
The exposed ceilings and pipes in this spot give it a rustic feel. You won’t want to miss the duck ragu which is one of their most popular dishes, especially if you’re looking for something unique to try.
This restaurant is perfect for a nice date night or to celebrate some special occasion with your family or friends.

Address: 53 Scollard Street, Toronto
Phone: (416) 962-2822

Customer Review:

"Kind friendly service and the food was ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE. definitely on the pricier side but the food was so so worth it. the care put into recipe development is extremely apparent. I am very full and very impressed! highly recommend! "
- Clarke Blair

6. Figo Toronto

Figo Toronto
Yelp/Chris A.
Figo Toronto is located on Adelaide Street. This Italian restaurant serves up some of the most beautiful dishes you will find in the city. The space is absolutely stunning with its soaring windows and open kitchen.
This restaurant has a great selection of wines and a lot of pasta options for you to choose from. Their menu also includes items like calamari fritti, bucatini and a variety of pizzas which will leave your taste buds craving more!
This spot is perfect for a dinner date with that special someone or to celebrate a special occasion with the family. The dishes here are small, but they are all extremely delicious.

Address: 295 Adelaide St W, Toronto
Phone: (647) 748-3446

Customer Review:

"We came here just for drink and dessert. We would be happy to come back and try a full meal. It was a lovely atmosphere, the servers were lovely keeping us informed about when the kitchen was closing in case we changed our minds. The prices were reasonable, cocktails were delicious, and the chocolate mousse was to die for. Can't wait to visit again and try something off there dinner menu!"
- Allysa C

5. La Vecchia Restaurant

La Vecchia Restaurant
Yelp/Queenie C.
This Italian restaurant is located in Midtown on Yonge St. This place is a great brunch spot or for people who are looking to have an amazing Italian dinner. The pasta options here are out of this world and the atmosphere is cozy and romantic.
This restaurant has a great wine list as well as a delicious cocktail menu. They also have a variety of dishes which include gnocchi ai quattro formaggi, carpaccio di manzo, capellini, and more.
La Vecchia Restaurant is a great spot for any occasion!

Address: 2405 Yonge St A, Toronto
Phone: (416) 489-0630

Customer Review:

"Booked reservations fairly last minute but what a great restaurant! Amazing atmosphere, great service, fantastic food - what more can you expect? Pictured: we ordered the PEI mussels in lemon garlic sauce, and the base was delicious. We shared the mushroom pasta, which was equally as good. Would highly recommend this restaurant."
- Tan

4. Piano Piano Restaurant

Piano Piano Restaurant

Yelp/Ada C.

Piano Piano Restaurant is located near Harbord & Spadina, this is an Italian restaurant that has a cozy vibe. They have an amazing patio perfect for dining in the summertime.
Their menu includes items like Parma Crudo, Mushroom Cavatelli, Bistecca al Pepe and lots of other pasta options as well as pizzas.
The service here is great too! Piano Piano Restaurant is definitely worth trying if you want to have an amazing night filled with great food and drinks.

Address: 88 Harbord St, Toronto
Phone: (416) 929-7788

Customer Review:

"Ambiance is quite dark indoors but beautiful design. Food was delicious. I tried: calamari, mushroom cavatelli, carrot cake and a gin and tonic. I loved the pasta, recommended by our server. The carrot cake is quite large so definitely share. Perfect place to catch up with friends or date night."
- Heidi Adia

3. Trattoria Nervosa

Trattoria Nervosa
Yelp/Min C.
Trattoria Nervosa is located in the heart of Yorkville. This restaurant has a rustic feel and a cozy atmosphere. This is the spot for a classic Italian meal.
On their menu, you will find things like truffle funghi pasta, grilled octopus, capellini pasta and a ton of other mouth-watering dishes.
The food here is amazing! The service at Trattoria Nervosa is also great. Plus they also have a lovely patio for those warm summer nights! If you’re looking for a great Italian meal in the heart of Yorkville, make sure you give Trattoria Nervosa a try.

Address: 75 Yorkville Ave, Toronto
Phone: (416) 961-4642

Customer Review:

"Went there today, the food was delicious and the service was excellent, they sat us in 5 min which was incredible! Especially on a Saturday, I thought we would wait at least half an hour, everything was fresh and tasty, a bit pricy though. The patio was beautiful and the whole atmosphere was lovely, would go again and I recommend it. Well done"
- Dania Baroni

2. Terroni

Terroni
Yelp/Min C.
Terroni is a popular spot in the city for Italian food, there are multiple locations all located in the downtown core.
Terroni has an extensive menu with lots of different pasta options and pizza. They also have some great items like spaghetti alla chitarra, duck confit and prosciutto and braised octopus.
The atmosphere at Terroni is also very nice. This restaurant is great for large groups so you can all enjoy their amazing food together. The service here is always top notch too!

Address: 57 Adelaide St E, Toronto
Phone: (416) 203-3093

Customer Review:

"First thing….fresh pasta. A true sign of a real Italian restaurant is that it serves fresh made pasta. Food quality was very high. The packing is very good as well. You pay for quality and its worth it. Keep up the great quality."
- Aswani Datt

1. Grazie Ristorante

Grazie Ristorante
The #1 on our list is Grazie Ristorante. This Italian restaurant has a classic and cozy feel and they offer amazing service! What makes this restaurant so special is that its menu has stayed consistent over the many years since it first opened.
Everything from the bread to the pasta and even their desserts here is out of this world! The food at Grazie Ristorante is made with fresh ingredients and lots of love. Their service and atmosphere make for a perfect night out, you will definitely want to go back again soon after trying it for the first time.
If you’re looking for some great Italian food in the city, you can’t go wrong with Grazie Ristorante!

Address: 2373 Yonge St, Toronto
Phone: (416) 488-0822

Customer Review:

"How WAS it? How IS it?!!!! This is, hands-down, one of the FINEST Italian spots in the city. Understated and unassuming yet hosting some of the most exquisite cuisine available. The Caesar salad will blow your mind. Remember to treat yourself every now and then and put Grazie on your list of "must tries"...you will NOT be disappointed 🙂 Preparation is everything and these fine men and women nail it...every...single...time. Wonderful staff and the ones you DON'T see will turn your world upside-down."
- Copper Dee

FAQs about Italian Restaurants in Toronto

Italian restaurants vary and can have a large variety of dishes. Most Italian menus include pizzas, pastas and salads. Some places also offer pasta options like gnocchi, ziti and penelle as well as sandwiches and soups too!  Italian restaurant

Yes, you can make reservations at an Italian restaurant. Usually, you can make reservations by calling the restaurant directly. How much should I tip at an Italian restaurant? The recommended amount to tip is 15 %, but it’s always nice to leave a little extra if the service was particularly good!

There are lots of options when dining at an Italian restaurant. Some good items to try are lasagna, caprese salad and chicken parmigiana.

Some suitable options that go well with Italian food include Chianti or Barbera. Those who enjoy red wine should definitely give Nero d’Avola a try, it’s a very popular type!

When a type of pasta is described as al dente, it just means that the pasta is not over-cooked. It’s best to avoid overcooking pasta dishes so that the noodles don’t become mushy.

Conclusion

We hope you enjoyed our list of the best Italian restaurants in Toronto. There are so many delicious spots to eat here in this city.
If you’re ever looking for a great Italian restaurant, make sure you check out one of these places first. You won’t be disappointed!
We wish you the best of luck on your next trip to Toronto and we hope that this list helped guide you in the right direction if you don’t know where to start next time you head out!
If you are also interested in some of the best Chinese restaurants in Toronto, we also have a page where you can find them.

You might also like...