The 10 Best Oysters in Toronto [2022]

Best Oysters in Toronto

Who knew that Toronto would be home to some of the best oyster spots in the country? While the city is better known for its poutine and maple syrup, there’s a growing number of places that are serving up fresh, delicious oysters. 

Here we compiled a list of the 10 best oyster spots in Toronto. We chose these restaurants based on the quality of their oysters, variety, value, reviews, and atmosphere.

Whether you’re looking for a casual spot to share a dozen with friends or an upscale restaurant for a special occasion, there’s something for everyone on this list. So grab a fork (or just slurp them straight from the shell) and enjoy!

Still thinking about delicious, fresh seafood?  Satisfy those cravings and do a seafood crawl. Stop by the best fish tacos in Toronto or get the best sushi in the city!

Summary

What are the Different Types of Oysters?

Most of Toronto’s oysters come from the east coast of Canada, specifically Nova Scotia. The three main types of oysters you’ll find in Toronto are Malpeques, Beausoleils, and Fanny Bays.

Malpeques are large and round with a light brininess. They’re one of the most popular types of oysters served in restaurants.

Beausoleils are smaller and more delicate than Malpeques. They have a milder taste with a hint of sweetness.

Fanny Bays are the largest type of oyster you’ll find in Toronto. They’re named after Fanny Bay, a small town on Vancouver Island in British Columbia. These oysters are slightly salty with a firm texture.

Now that you know a little bit about the different types of oysters, let’s get to the good part: where to find them!

The Best Oyster Spots in Toronto

Now that you know a little bit more about oysters, it’s time to eat! Here are the 10 best oyster spots in Toronto: in Toronto.

1. Rodney’s Oyster House

Rodney’s Oyster House is the go-to spot for seafood lovers looking for the freshest and best-tasting seafood around. That’s because they take seafood seriously at Rodney’s, importing their own oysters, lobsters and king crab from some of the best waters in the world. 

And with their federal import licenses, they’re able to bring in these delicious catches more quickly than other restaurants, so you can enjoy them at their peak of freshness. With so many delicious options to choose from, there’s something for everyone at Rodney’s Oyster House.

So come on down and enjoy some of the best seafood around!

Business Information:

rodneysoysterhouse.com
foh@rodneysoysterhouse.com
+14163638105
469 King St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1K4, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“This was our first time at Rodney's and certainly will not be our last. The oysters were fresh, I loved the shrimp & grits and the Sea Fry was delicious. Staff was friendly & helpful and the ambiance was quite nice.”

2. Oyster Boy

If you’re looking for some of the best oysters in town, there’s no better place to go than Oyster Boy. This popular Toronto seafood spot has been sourcing the finest oysters and seafood from coast to coast since they first opened shop in the city’s bustling Queen West District. They’re proud to be Canada’s most popular restaurant, caterer or wholesaler for all your oyster needs!

The selection of oysters at this shop is great and you’ll be hard-pressed to find better service. They sell Beausoleil oysters, which are a cocktail size of a French Kiss oyster. And with sources like Oyster Boy Hot Banana Pepper Sauce, you’re guaranteed to get the best experience possible. 

So if you’re looking for the freshest seafood in town, make sure to swing by Oyster Boy and see what all the fuss is about!

Business Information:

info@oysterboy.ca
+14165343432
872 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1G3, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Their oysters were really fresh, we got a shuckers dozen. There was a mix of east coast and west coast oysters. The servers did a great job of explaining the different kinds and the textures. Their banana pepper hot sauce was also amazing. Would definitely come back again for a meal!”

3. Honest Weight

Nestled on the docks of the historic district, The Fish House is a seafood lover’s paradise. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh-caught fish, succulent oysters, or crabs pulled straight from the trap, they have got what’s on the menu and ready to go. 

You can also pick up at their retail counter some of the same great seafood to take home and cook yourself. They have a variety of oysters to choose from, not just the ones that grow in cages. Most people come here because they’re looking for something different or more uncommon than what you’ll find at your average grocery store. 

It’s also great for those who aspire to freshness and flavor without any fuss! So next time you’re in the mood for some truly delicious seafood, be sure to swing by The Fish House. You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:

honestweight.ca
info@honestweight.ca
+14166049992
2766 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1Y3, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“One of the best and the most original menus for a seafood oriented restaurant. We had a very great time being served by a kind lady. The food was amazing. I tasted the soup and burger made of cod and shrimp and also a delicious pastry at the end. Even the drinks are freshly prepared here. If you love fish this is a must go place.”

4. John & Sons Oyster House

John & Sons Oyster House is a hidden gem in the heart of the city! This seafood restaurant has an excellent selection of menu items, ranging from oysters to cooked meats. They also have a wine list with great choices for any occasion! 

The staff here is friendly and helpful – they will recommend the best and the freshest oysters for you. The oysters here are very fresh and have an excellent variety. Staff here also seem really friendly; service is prompt without being overbearing. 

You can easily enjoy a quiet romantic date there or grab some oysters with friends. John & Sons Oyster House is the perfect place for any seafood lover!

Business Information:

johnandsonsoysterhouse.com
john@johnandsonsoysterhouse.com
+14165045111
56 Temperance St, Toronto, ON M5H 3V5, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Outstanding seafood spot. Cozy and warm. Great service. Perfectly prepared cod. Oysters are as good as you get in toronto.”

5. Pearl Diver

Pearl Diver is a family-owned seafood restaurant has been serving up fresh fish and oysters for decades. The sauces here are incredible, with flavors that you can’t find anywhere else! Their menu is huge and everything is delicious from the Caesar salad with real sardines to freshly shucked oysters. 

The 100 Oysters for $100 Thursdays are the best day to get your fix of fresh oysters. You can always enjoy them with in-house cocktail sauce, horseradish or Tabasco – it’s so hard not to be tempted by these deals!

Business Information:

pearldiver.to
info@pearldiver.to
+14163667827
100 Adelaide St E, Toronto, ON M5C 1K9, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Really tasty food, oysters were a nice treat. The staff really know a lot about oysters, and were happy to share that knowledge with us. It was very informative and I would definitely recommend this place to anyone. I will be back in the future for that seafood tower”

6. Pure Spirits

Looking for a delicious and sustainable seafood option? Pure Spirits is the place for you! They specialize in oysters that are perfect for all palettes. Whether you’re looking for something sweet or salty, they have an oyster for you. In addition to being delicious, their oysters are also sourced sustainably. So you can feel good about enjoying their seafood! 

If you’re looking for a fun and festive menu item, be sure to check out their seasonal mains. They have shareable sides that are perfect for any event. Trust us, your guests will be impressed! For an elegant dinner option, look no further than Pure Spirits. Their menu is sure to please everyone at your table.

Business Information:

purespirits.ca
ebottomley@thedistillery.ca
+14163615859
17 Tank House Lane, Toronto, ON M5A 3C4, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Oysters were fresh & delicious, and the cocktail was also great. But the real standouts in this spot are the staff, namely Julia & Patricia who went above and beyond the call with kindness and generosity and perfect service!”

7. Harbour 60 Toronto

When the Toronto Harbour Commission first opened its doors, it was just a small operation in what is now known as the New Toronto neighbourhood. Today, the commission is a world-renowned oyster restaurant with a private dining room that is perfect for special occasions. The restaurant’s oysters are sourced from all over the world and are carefully selected for their freshness and quality. 

The variety of oysters on offer means that there is something for everyone to enjoy, whether you are a beginner or an experienced oyster lover. Whether you are looking for a romantic dinner for two or a fun night out with friends, the Toronto Harbour Commission is the perfect place to enjoy fresh oysters and delicious seafood.

Business Information:

harbour60.com
events@harboursixty.com
+14167772111
60 Harbour St, Toronto, ON M5J 1B7, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“By far one of the most reliable restaurants in Toronto in terms of quality, service and overall ambiance. Their wine selection is exceptional and extensive, they always have a sommelier present as well. If you're a fan of oysters, I would argue and say this is probably the best spot for oysters in the city.”

8. The Chase

There’s nothing like enjoying a meal with great company, and at The Chase, you’re guaranteed both. This seafood restaurant is known for their outstanding oysters, and rightly so – they’re the best you’ll ever have. But that’s not all The Chase has to offer. 

Their sea bass dish is absolutely mouthwatering, and their pasta is so refreshingly delicious. It’s clear that the service here has a personal touch – they really make you feel at home.

 With such amazing food and wonderful service, it’s no wonder The Chase is one of the most popular seafood restaurants around. So next time you’re looking for a dining experience that’s truly special, be sure to pay them a visit. You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:

thechasetoronto.com
info@chasehg.com
+16473487000
10 Temperance St Fl 5, Toronto, ON M5H 1Y4, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Great location, great seafood, great service, great experience. The servers are very hospitable and accommodating. The food is always delicious. The views are scenic and beautiful. We always look forward to our next dining experience at The Chase.”

9. Scaramouche Restaurant

If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience, look no further than Scaramouche. Whether you’re in the mood for French cuisine with stunning skyline views or Italian pasta, they have something for everyone. 

One of their signature dishes is the freshest oysters on the half shell, served with lemon, horseradish and red wine mignonette. But it’s not just the food that makes Scaramouche so special – it’s also the impeccable service and accompanying dishes that will make your evening one to remember. 

So if you’re looking for a truly unique dining experience, be sure to check out Scaramouche. You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:

scaramoucherestaurant.com
scaramouche@rogers.com
+14169618011
1 Benvenuto Pl, Toronto, ON M4V 2L1, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“Absolutely wonderful from start to finish. Started off the night with complimentary valet and coat check. Ordered the Yellowfin Tuna tartare and oysters as our appetizers. Both were phenomenal!”

10. Azarias Restaurant

If you’re looking for a delicious, affordable meal that will leave you wanting more, then you need to head to Azarias Restaurant. The food is amazing and flavorful, the service impeccable, and the atmosphere is so much fun! 

Their menu ranges from delicious burgers and fries to amazing seafood pastas and appetizers. You should try their oysters, which are delivered straight from the best farms in Canada. You can also order lots of small plates to try everything. The place is really nice and cozy. 

So what are you waiting for? Make your reservations now and enjoy an unforgettable dining experience at Azarias Restaurant!

Business Information:

azariasrestaurant.com
+16473528448
3058 Bloor St W, Etobicoke, ON M8X 1C4, Canada

Customer Review Highlight:

“We love Azaria's! The food, service and wine were amazing. The oysters were very fresh and the lobster gnocchi and scallops were to die for. We will definitely be back.”

FAQs About Oysters

There is no right or wrong way to eat oysters. Some people like to add a squeeze of lemon or a dash of hot sauce, while others prefer to eat them plain. It’s really up to you! Oysters from most seafood markets or directly from the restaurant. Ask your server for recommendations if you’re unsure of where to start.
Oysters are best eaten within 2 days of purchase. After that, they start to lose their freshness and flavour.
The best way to tell if an oyster is fresh is to give it a smell. If it smells fishy or off, it’s probably not fresh and you should send it back. Also, take a look at the oyster. It should have a plump body with tightly closed shells. If the oyster is shrivelled up or the shells are open, it’s not fresh.
Oysters are native to both the east and west coasts of North America. However, most of the oysters you’ll find in Toronto are from the East Coast.

Final Thoughts

Through the years, oysters have become essential in fine dining. It makes sense, they’re an expensive delicacy and they seem to be a hit with everyone. There are many amazing oyster restaurants all over Toronto. If you have never tried oysters before or you’re a seasoned pro, any of these Toronto oyster spots all have amazing food. So take your pick, and get to shucking those oysters!

You might also like...