11 Best Places to Get Pies in Toronto

“ Delicious peanut butter pie with a Ritz cracker crust and a sprinkle of flakey salt”

Best Places to Get Pies in Toronto Web Story

This blog is for you if you are a pie lover like us who enjoys eating pie regularly, whether it is a holiday or not. We’ve compiled a list of the top bakeries in Toronto that serve some of the best and most delectable pies of all types that will transport you back to your grandmother’s kitchen. If you’re not sure where to start hunting for these mouthwatering delicacies, check out our list of the best 11 places to get pies in Toronto.

11) Sharman's Proper Pies

Have you ever eaten a pie prepared with an oatmeal brown ale? Then Sharman’s Proper pies should undoubtedly be on your list. They use Eephus from “Left Fields Brewery” in their steak and ale pie. This creation is absolutely a match made in heaven that you should give a shot. You should also try their other delectable pie meals, such as steak and kidney pie, chicken pot pie, and steak and cheese pie, all of which start at $10.45. Sharman’s also allows you to create your own sample box by selecting five different pie flavours to sample for your next order, which can be delivered to your door for $50 before tax.

Address: 1972 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4C 1J6 
Phone: +14169017437 
Instagram: Sharman’s Proper Pies (@sharmansproper)

10) Dough Bakeshop

This bakery is situated on Danforth Ave, near Broadview Station. This bakery prepares fresh and tasty homemade pastries created from scratch on-site and are great for any time of day in their cozy establishment. Our favourite pies are the key lime pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, and banana cream pie, all of which are available in individual or full-size sizes. If you are planning to get full-size desserts, pre-order some pies, such as the banana cream pie, which also requires a 48-hour notice. Don’t forget to try their pumpkin pie which will have you coming back for more.

Address: 173 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4K 1N2 
Phone:+14164652253 
Instagram: Dough Bakeshop (@dough.bakeshop)

9) Bunner's Bakeshop

This bakery is known for its pink-coloured storefront as well as its vegan and gluten-free baked goods. This bakery also serves various sweet and savoury pastries, including cupcakes, cheesecakes, ice creams, pies, and more. If a crumbly crust is your favourite part of a pie, try their key lime pie, which is our top favourite and prepared from scratch for $22.95.

Address:244 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2L7 
Address: 3054 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1Z7
Phone: +16473502975 
Instagram: Bunner’s Bake Shop (@bunner)

8) Sweetie Pie

Sweetie Pie is the place to go if you’re searching for a special dessert created with love. The bakeshop provides an excellent range of pastries and pies at a reasonable cost, all of which are created with fresh ingredients that you will enjoy. Spicy beef curry and vegan mushroom pies are two of our favourites from their savoury pie menu. Also, try their apple, blueberry, and cherry pies, which are all vegan and if you like a little sweet treat during your day. Don’t forget to stop by this fantastic store to try out their delicious pies between the hours of 9:30 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. every day of the week.

Address: 326 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M6G 1H1 
Phone: +16472453301
Instagram: My Sweetie Pie (@mysweetiepie.ca)

7) The Rolling Pin

This bakery has a clean and well-organized shop and an open, spacious interior and eating space. The bakery provides a large range of delicacies that you simply cannot pass on. Despite the fact that their donuts are attractive and make you want to taste every flavour, their pies are on another level. “Candy Bar Pie” with velvety peanut butter, cream cheese mousse and a pretzel crust is one of our favourite tastes from their pie offerings. You should also try their chocolate pumpkin pie, which is a traditional pumpkin pie with a thick coating of chocolate ganache. All of their pies start at $25 and are 9 inches, with enough filling to satisfy up to 8 people.

Address: 1970 Avenue Rd, North York, ON M5M 4A1 
Phone: +14166914554 
Instagram: The Rolling Pin (@therollingpinto)

6) Bakerbots Baking

This bakery, located near Ossington station, serves a range of desserts, coffee and excellent pies. All of their treats are very appealing, making you want to try everything, but we’ll make it simpler for you by recommending their key lime pie, which is soft and tasty. You should also try their wild blueberry pie, which is likewise fruity and sweet. It’s best if you preorder your pies a week ahead of time. They also have small pies if you’re simply eating alone and can’t have too much sugar.

Address: 205 Delaware Ave, Toronto, ON M6H 2T4 
Phone: +14169013500 
Instagram: bakerbotsbaking (@bakerbots_baking)

5) Danish Pastry Shop

11 Best Places to Get Pies in Toronto
“Delicious apple pie that goes well with a hot cup of tea”
Danish Pastry Shop located at Pape Ave and Gowan Ave is another hidden gem in Toronto for the best pies. This small, friendly bakery offers a wide variety of freshly made cookies, cream puffs, bread, and pies, all at a reasonable price. Their meat pie is to die for, and their steak pie is savoury and delicious; it’s some of the local favourites that you also should give a try.

Address: 1017 Pape Ave, East York, ON M4K 3V8 
Phone: +14164258877

4) The Pie Commission

The pie commission is located in Etobicoke, which is about a half-hour drive from Toronto. This is a take-out restaurant that serves hand-made savoury pies that are tasty and ready to eat, or you can purchase a frozen pie to heat up and eat at the comfort of your home. Butter chicken, beef and beer, and “Veg-ilicious,” a vegetarian pie made with kale, broccoli, cauliflower, and homemade basil sauce, are among their savoury pie options. They also offer seasonal pies as well as a 5″ individual size pie. Don’t forget to try their braised rib pie; you won’t be disappointed.

Address: 927 The Queensway, Etobicoke, ON M8Z 5Z7
Phone:+14168487424 
Instagram: The Pie Commission (@thepiecommission)

3) Pie Squared

Pie squared has solved the science of pie. They use fresh ingredients and prepare their pie from scratch. The stuffing is big, tasty, and satisfying, and the pie crust has just the proper amount of texture that crumbles when you bite into it. Their menu also includes individualized-sized pizza pies, yes pizza and pie together. If you like both, you should try this unique sort of pie, which is very filling and comforting. Try their UFO pizza for just $14.95. Their savoury pies also include butter chicken for $8.85 and a key lime pie jar with toasted coconut and banana for only $5.95. They also provide frozen pies at a great price, with two frozen savoury pies for just $16.95.

Address: 366 Bloor St E, Toronto, Ontario M4W 1H4 
Phone: +16473497432 
Instagram: Pie Squared (@pie2squared)

2) Phipps Bakery and Dessert Shop

You wanted to serve pie at your family dinner but don’t have time to prepare it? Don’t worry; Phipps Bakery has you covered. Phipps Bakery and Dessert Shop offer tasty and satisfying handcrafted family pies. You can have a pie up to 11 inches! For just $58.99, that serves up to ten people. Their bakery also includes a dining area with vintage touches and decoders such as blue and white ceramic works, plants, and paintings on the wall that make the space look like an art show which is fascinating and appealing. While you’re there, don’t forget to sample their award-winning chocolate pecan pie, which is one of our favourites from their pie menu.

Address: 420 Eglinton Ave W, Toronto, ON M5N 1A2 
Phone:+14164819111 
Instagram: Phipps Bakery (@phippsbakery)

1) Wanda’s Pie in the Sky

Wanda’s Pie in the Sky offers one of the freshest pies in town in their brightly adorned shop. The shop is conveniently situated near College St and Bathurst St. Bright turquoise wall paint, colourful chairs, baked products, and mugs give the cafe a vintage feel. Raspberry rhubarb, sweet and creamy banana cream and pumpkin pie are just a few of our favourites from their pie menu that we also recommend you to try. The store has also been awarded a Trip Advisor certificate of excellence. Visit Wanda’s Pie Shop during store hours, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. every day of the week.

Address: 287 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2M2 
Phone: +14162367585 
Instagram: Wanda’s Pie In The Sky (@wandaspieinthesky)

The best places to get pies in Toronto are:

  • Wanda’s Pie in the Sky
  • Phipps Bakery and Dessert Shop
  • Pie Squared
  • The Pie Commission
  • Danish Pastry Shop
  • Bakerbots Baking
  • The Rolling Pin
  • Sweetie Pie
  • Bunner’s Bakeshop
  • Dough Bakeshop
  • Sharman’s Proper pies
That concludes our list of Toronto’s best places to get pies. We hope you liked reading this post and that it will help you choose your new favourite pie shop. Also, keep an eye on our daily updates for additional food recommendations and the best things to do in Toronto.

You might also like...

Toronto Blogs - Toronto Local News

Business Listings

Terms & Conditions

Privacy Policy

Sitemap