The 12 Best Seafood Restaurants in Toronto [2024]

  • Last updated: November 14, 2023

We conduct thorough testing and research on all the services that we review. We are based in Toronto and here is why you can rely on our reviews.

Get ready to dive into Toronto’s diverse seafood scene! From casual favorites to upscale delights, our specially curated list of the top twelve eateries will satisfy every seafood lover. Offering a range of dishes that star the freshest catches, these culinary hotspots promise an indulgent experience. 

And if you’re still hungry for more, check out our lists of the finest fish and chips and crawfish spots in Toronto. Get ready to indulge in the city’s vibrant seafood scene!

Summary

How We Chose Our Top Seafood Restaurants

When selecting our top 12, we considered a number of criteria including:
  • Variety: A wide range of seafood options is a must in any great seafood restaurant. Whether you prefer lobster, salmon or Sushi, there should be something for everyone on the menu.
  • Freshness: What’s on the menu is only half the story. It takes incredible care and dedication to ensure that restaurants are serving up fresh seafood. We wanted our selections to boast exemplary standards of quality, taste and presentation.
  • Dining Experience: Vibes and atmosphere are just as important as the food itself. You can have the freshest catch brought right to your table but if your restaurant is dingy and dirty, would you really want to eat there? We loved that each of these restaurants offers a truly unique experience, setting them apart from the rest.
  • Customer Reviews: We all know that one person who has the best recommendations when it comes to food (it might even be you!). We wanted our list to reflect what others are saying about these top restaurants.

The Best Seafood Restaurants in Toronto

Now that you know what criteria we used to select the restaurants on our list, let’s get to some of the best seafood in Toronto!

1. Rodney’s Oyster House

At Rodney’s, they’re all about fresh seafood, and it shows. Enjoy top-notch shrimp & grits, or their highly commended Sea Fry dish in an atmosphere that feels just like home, thanks to the friendly staff.

Business Information:

Address: 469 King St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1K4
Phone: (416) 363-8105
Website: rodneysoysterhouse.com

Customer Review Highlight:

Amazing food. The oyster selection post covid isn't as good as before but still excellent. Super friendly. A bit of a reduced menu as compared to before but still some of the best oysters in Toronto. Highly suggest the octopus! Best octopus I've had!!
- Wilfred Tam
"Amazing! The food is fresh, the service is superb and the place is just at another level. We were served by Lauren, an absolute delight! She made our experience a special one. This is definitely a hidden gem.. check out their washrooms!"
- Kal Sukkar

2. Fishman Lobster Clubhouse Restaurant

A family-owned seafood restaurant since 2009. Known for their vast variety of seafood options, especially their famed lobster and crab towers. The banquet hall-style interior sets a cozy mood.

Business Information:

Address: 4020 Finch Ave E, Scarborough, ON M1S 3T6
Phone: (416) 321-0250
Website: flctoronto.com

Customer Review Highlight:

More expensive than what it used to be, but the portion sizes are still relative. Staff are very friendly and service is great. Food is delicious, as always. They follow Covid protocols very strictly and I feel very safe dining there.
- Jasmine T
"Went with 4 people, ordered 8lbs of Hong Kong style lobster, beef with black bean sauce, lobster fried rice and it was all 10/10. Price was very in line with the value you get. Wine prices were also awesome. Top 3 restaurant of mine for sure!"
- Giovanni Albano

3. Diana's Oyster Bar and Grill

Diana’s Seafood boosts three decades in the business. Expect an awesome selection of oysters and a diverse menu inspired globally. Visit if you fancy a personal, friendly service.

Business Information:

Address: 7501 Woodbine Ave, Markham, ON L3R 2W1
Phone: (905) 415-7792
Website: dianasoysterbar.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"First time at this restaurant after it was recommended to me by a friend. Excellent service and seafood, especially the delicious oysters. The Waiter was attentive and provided great recommendations for oysters and main courses. Will be back soon!"
- Kenneth R. Bandeira
Very good meal. Started with the dollar oysters and mussels. Lobster and shrimp tagliatelle was very good. Ended the meal with a tiramasu which was also very good.
- Adrian Lee

4. Pearl Diver

Classic seafood, vegan options and craft beers define this family-friendly spot. The seafood tower and starters are highly recommended. Plus, the knowledgeable staff can help guide you through your oyster journey.

Business Information:

Address: 100 Adelaide St E, Toronto, ON M5C 1K9
Phone: (416) 366-7827
Website:  pearldiver.to

Customer Review Highlight:

"Great seafood. Highly recommend their seafood tower and starters to share and their scallop/pork appetizer was honestly my favourite dish here. Lobster was tasty but I wish I got their lobster roll instead."
- Tomoya
"Really tasty food, oysters were a nice treat. The staff really know a lot about oysters, and were happy to share that knowledge with us. It was very informative and I would definitely recommend this place to anyone. I will be back in the future for that seafood tower "
- Kelvin Phillip

5. San Antonio Seafood Market & Oyster Bar Ltd.

For fresh oysters, delicatedly seasoned seafood dishes and crafted cocktails in a warm and stylish setting. The welcoming staff and great service make it all the more appealing.

Business Information:

Address: 8383 Weston Rd, Woodbridge, ON L4L 0K7
Phone: (905) 856-2000
Website: sanantonioseafood.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

"Amazing service and some of the best Italian food I've had. The caesar dressing is nice and light, the oysters are fresh, and their red sauce is very well balanced and perfectly compliments their pasta and seafood. Would highly recommend!"
- Phong Pham
"We stopped here to shop for fresh fish, but decided to have lunch. If you're looking for good food, come to San Antonio Seafood! Great food, great service!!! Will be back for sure!! "
- teresa anania

6. Market Street Catch

This maritime destination, nested within Downtown Toronto, offers a delightful variety of seafood, from octopus tacos to lobster rolls. So, whether you’re in a rush or want to leisurely enjoy your seafood, Market Street Catch is perfect for you!

Business Information:

Address: 14 Market St., Toronto, ON M5E 1C3
Phone: (416) 363-2020
Website: marketstreetcatch.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

"Great experience at this location. The service was good and the food was exceptional. I really enjoyed the swordfish and fries, but I think the fish needed more seasoning rather than just the sauce on the side. The portion to price is on point. Will definitely be back."
- Amarjit Dhamrait
"Always fresh and great. The price is acceptable the portions are big. Also the stuff is friendly. I am really glad they are able to offer food on their patio once again."
- Petre Ene

7. Adega Restaurante

Blending old recipes and modern flavors – that’s Adega’s secret! This upscale, intimate space offers Portuguese and Spanish dishes paired with an extensive Portuguese wine list – it’s truly an exciting culinary adventure.

Business Information:

Address: 33 Elm St, Toronto, ON M5G 1H1
Phone: (416) 977-4338
Website: adegarestaurante.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

"We ordered the fixed menu and enjoyed every bite. The food was delicious especially the grilled squid. We had a problem with one of our dishes but the waiter fixed it immediately. Great service. Very attentive. Would go back again. A+"
- Jane Doe
"My boyfriend and I agree that this is the best restaurant food we’ve ever had. We both loved the grilled squid, and the Atlantic salmon with the pineapple compote is to die for. The staff was friendly and restaurant was nice. Overall I highly recommend it, it was a fantastic experience!"
- Michaela Tellis

8. Joso's

With 43 years in business, Joso’s brings the warmth and beauty of the Dalmatian coast to Toronto. This landmark offers the best Italian seafood like grilled octopus and lamb chops and ensures every dish is perfection itself.

Business Information:

Address: 202 Davenport Rd, Toronto, ON M5R 1J2
Phone: (416) 925-1903
Website: josos.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"My new fav restaurant! Amazing food and atmosphere. The staff were very friendly, helpful and attentive. The squid ink pasta was the best pasta I’ve ever had very creamy and light. The tiramisu and gelato were great."
- Dana
"Joso's is a Toronto institution. If you like seafood, and you haven't been, stop reading this and make a reservation. Hmm...you are still reading... I am jealous of you, you get to go to Joso's for the first time - don't spoil it by learning more - let Joso's draw you in and delight your senses. "
- Renee Hill

9. Zee Grill Seafood Restaurant & Oyster Bar

As Toronto’s oldest oyster bar, Zee Grill knows their seafood. Run by owners Chef Jac Eckhardt and sommelier, Beth, this establishment promises top-notch meals from a cozy, elegant atmosphere.

Business Information:

Address: 641 Mt Pleasant Rd, Toronto, ON M4S 2M9
Phone: (416) 484-6428
Website: zeegrill.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"Great seafood place! My husband and I enjoyed tasty oysters and I had perfectly grilled calamari. There was a large selection of wine and beer. Love the location. The staff was quick and friendly. A must try! "
- Alanna Cassells
"Had a fantastic dinner here. The sea bass was cooked to perfection: crispy skin and buttery soft flesh. My partner had the seafood soup which was also incredible. Good wine, great service and a sticky toffee pudding to cap it off. Best seafood we have had since our last vacation"
- Beth Sunnucks

10. John & Sons Oyster House

Right in downtown Toronto, John & Sons pledge to fresh and sustainable dishes, showcased in their East Coast delights

Business Information:

Address: 56 Temperance St, Toronto, ON M5H 3V5
Phone: (416) 504-5111
Website: johnandsonsoysterhouse.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"Oysters oysters oysters!! You can't go wrong when deciding to dine here. Nice ambience, great food at a reasonable price (lobster roll was delish for just under $30) and friendly service. A must go before games"
- Federica Cecchini
"This place is awesome! Wonderfully warm service, with a tasty and unintimidating menu. Everyone makes you feel like a regular by the time you finish your first meal. The food is simple, fresh, and extremely flavorful. Absolute gem! "
- Chris Tang

11. Stamp’s Lane

This Canadian gem is an icon for local and seasonal delicacies. Charmingly situated on Roncesvalles Ave, the cuisine oscillates with the seasons, keeping things fresh and interesting. Stamp’s Lane impresses with plates like NB oysters and luxurious lobster Mac. A flavour journey every Toronto native deserves.

Business Information:

Address: 371 Roncesvalles Ave, Toronto, ON M6R 2M8
Phone: (416) 537-7750
Website: stampslane.com

Customer Review Highlight:

"Highly recommend. Especially if your a fan of seafood from the east coast. Their NB oysters were fantastic. Also really enjoyed the lobster Mac. They had full chunks of lobster in it which you don’t see often. The entire experience was definitely worthy of coming back multiple times!!! "
- Katrina Xavier
"First time to Stamp's Lane and loved it. Lobster Mac'n'Cheese was awesome, tasty oysters and excellent house smoked salmon. Can't wait to return. Thanks!!!!"
- d rhodes

12. Honest Weight

This seafood haven situated on Dundas St W blends the best of seafood cuisine in a relaxed environment. From a luscious brunch of fish-focused delights to elegant Tuna Tataki at dinner, it’s a true seafood lover’s paradise. With an excellent wine list, Honest Weight guarantees a memorable culinary escapade.

Business Information:

Address: 2766 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1Y3
Phone: (416) 604-9992
Website: honestweight.ca

Customer Review Highlight:

“Amazing dinner experience and the dishes were cooked to perfection. This is my second time visiting and I continue to be blown away. Had the tuna tartare, the chowder, the scallops and the pick your fish option with the cod and all the dishes exceeded my expectations! Will definitely be back.”
- Elaine Lewis
“Great seafood restaurant, everything is fresh, full of flavours, and cooked to perfection. My favourites were the soups.The service was the best.”
- Kelly Chan

FAQs About Seafood

Some of the most popular seafood dishes in Toronto are lobster rolls, fried calamari, sushi, oysters and octopus tacos.
Some of the best ways to tell if seafood in a restaurant is fresh are whether it smells like seawater, has firm flesh and isn’t slimy.
It’s recommended that you eat no more than 6-12 oysters per day.
Some of the best drinks to enjoy with seafood are champagne, white wine, red wine and beer.

Conclusion

Toronto truly is a seafood lover’s paradise. With a wealth of exceptional restaurants delivering wonderfully crafted plates from the ocean’s bounty, the city shines as a beacon of culinary excellence. Whether you prefer a chill vibe or a fancy outing, these twelve hand-picked restaurants reflect Toronto’s dedication to offer the finest seafood experience. 

Veronika Zotova

Veronika Zotova

Veronika Zotova is marketing manager at Local View Tech. She was born and raised in Kyiv, Ukraine. Learn More About Veronika Zotova

You might also like...

Toronto Blogs - Toronto Local News

Business Listings

Terms & Conditions

Privacy Policy

Sitemap